acquisto cialis on line price of cialis in india cialis young cialis achat france cialis kaufen billig cost for cialis for daily use cheap cialis sale women take cialis can i buy cialis over the counter cialis en france achat cialis impotence buy cialis brand online maximum dosage of cialis maximum dosage for cialis buying cialis from canada cost of cialis daily use 20 mg cialis reviews cialis suppliers in the uk cialis for daily use price cialis en madrid daily cialis generic cialis 20mg review cialis online legal cialis and drug interactions cialis pills 20mg cialis suppliers uk cialis vendita online cialis au meilleur prix cost of cialis with prescription price cialis india arginine et cialis cialis prescription usa cialis sale cheap cialis vente en france 10mg cialis generic similar al cialis cialis 5 mg online ' cialis achat en france buy cialis online us can buy cialis over counter cialis and arginine cialis kaufen 20mg cialis maximum dosage cialis dose maximum is cialis safe to take how to buy cialis online usa cialis daily use price cialis from germany purchasing cialis para que serve o cialis prescription cialis cost what is the effect of cialis on women cheap overnight cialis how to cut a cialis in half what is the best time to take cialis what is the maximum dosage of cialis cialis effect time when to take cialis best time to take what is the maximum dose of cialis cialis schedule cialis price india cialis and impotence cialis purchase australia achat cialis en france achat cialis 20 mg when is best time to take cialis cialis cheap overnight cialis prices in canada compare generic cialis cialis preturi the best time to take cialis similar to cialis cialis online review cialis medico where to buy brand cialis online cialis generika bestellen cialis vente en ligne cialis sydney 25 mg cialis cialis in montreal cost cialis prescription cialis daily generic cialis on line forum cialis with arginine achat de cialis en france cialis en peru buy cialis store cialis in ontario prijs cialis preisvergleich cialis 20 mg generic cialis daily cheapest cialis in uk buying cheap cialis online cialis 20 mg review patent expiration cialis cialis deutschland kaufen cialis obat kuat how to split cialis acheter cialis forum cialis in sydney cialis with flomax buy generic cialis no prescription cialis florida cialis prix de vente how to buy cialis on the internet acheter du cialis 20 mg cialis 5 mg cost cialis look like can you drink and take cialis cialis and anxiety cialis for anxiety cialis 20 mg costo cialis in portugal buy cialis internet cialis recreational www cialis com free offer cialis is not working vente cialis en ligne cheapest uk cialis cialis articles cialis for benign prostatic hypertrophy cialis erfahrungsberichte cost of cialis prescription cialis aus deutschland kaufen cialis en france vente achat cialis 20mg costo cialis 20 mg dosage for cialis 20mg cialis effect women cost of daily use cialis daily use cialis price cialis 20mg acheter cialis in vancouver vente de cialis en france cialis 20 lilly cialis tanio paypal cialis canada 20mg cialis reviews lilly cialis 20 generic cialis in australia price for cialis 10mg cialis 20 mg precio brand cialis purchase price of daily use cialis cialis kaufen deutschland cialis 5 mg 28 legal cialis online ou acheter du cialis forum acheter cialis 20 purchase cialis professional long term effects cialis obat kuat cialis cialis supply cialis generico on line celebrex and cialis seroquel cialis pharmacy cialis prices generic cialis compare best cheap cialis erfahrungsberichte mit cialis uk cialis suppliers cialis for recreational acheter cialis 20mg cialis farmacia online precio cialis 20 mg achat cialis france canada cialis prices uk suppliers of cialis price of cialis for daily use effect cialis women cialis em portugal maximum dose for cialis cialis posologie cialis for depression why is cialis not working cialis cheapest uk generic cialis on sale cialis 20 costo price cialis daily use cialis generic daily cialis cost prescription cheap cialis in australia cost cialis daily use cialis en colombia cialis with prescription cost cialis price daily use cialis 20mg achat levitra medicamento 100 mg levitra order levitra cheap using levitra cheapest levitra online levitra what does it do when should i take levitra brand levitra online levitra video levitra 20 mg price levitra originale levitra rezeptfrei bestellen como tomar levitra levitra prezzo farmacia when do i take levitra levitra website levitra bestellen ohne rezept cheapest levitra generic order generic levitra bula do levitra levitra online uk levitra china levitra wordpress what does levitra do price of levitra 20mg levitra no rx online levitra uk levitra 20mg price que es el medicamento levitra levitra effective how levitra works levitra free sample levitra kaufen rezeptfrei levitra posologia levitra como tomar female levitra price of levitra 20 mg generic brand for levitra cheapest online levitra levitra costi is levitra effective levitra price 20 mg levitra online forum cheapest generic levitra levitra pricing effects of viagra on woman email viagra virus email virus viagra expired cialis find search viagra edinburgh pages find search viagra pages edinburgh find viagra edinburgh pages search find viagra edinburgh search pages find viagra pages edinburgh search free 6 viagra free generic shipping viagra free mail viagra free sex viagra generic 10mg cialis generic cialis softtabs generic pal pay viagra generic viagra and pay pal generic viagra cheapest uk generic viagra compared german viagra gnc viagra how to safely buy viagra online i doser viagra inventor viagra kamagra fake kamagra soft tabs kamagra website l-arginine viagra ladies viagra lawsuit viagra legal online cialis legitimate cialis mature viagra medicaid viagra naked viagra nitric oxide viagra no prescription order viagra online online pharmacy cheap viagra overseas buy viagra pages edinburgh search viagra find pills viagra canada stars on viagra prescription cheapest viagra professional viagra cheap search viagra edinburgh find pages search viagra find edinburgh pages search viagra viagra find edinburgh pages social viagra split cialis stories about cialis stories cialis testimonials cialis the language of viagra tijuana viagra viagra abuse viagra affiliate viagra anal viagra and affiliate viagra beer viagra best deal viagra blindness viagra cheap uk buy purchase viagra cheapest pharmacy viagra cocktail viagra coffee viagra compare cost viagra composition viagra discount drug viagra dogal viagra edinburgh search find pages viagra effects on woman viagra ejaculations viagra find edinburgh pages search viagra find edinburgh search pages viagra for sale site viagra for sexual dysfunction viagra from tijuana viagra generic soft tab viagra gnc viagra in uk reviews viagra inventor viagra lasting viagra lawsuit viagra nitrates viagra no prescription in usa viagra no prescription online cheap viagra online pharmacy cheap viagra pages search edinburgh find viagra phuket viagra profesional viagra sildenafil oral jelly viagra sperm viagra uk cheap purchase buy viagra viagra find edinburgh pages search viagra viagra find pages edinburgh search viagra were to buy viagra zonder recept video of viagra sex walmart generic viagra what is maximum dosage of viagra what is maximum dose for cialis why doesnt viagra work cialis women take and flomax cialis buy cialis from usa online buy cialis online say wordpress capsule cialis cialis and long term effects cialis and viagra purchase online cialis colombia cialis flomax cialis flomax and cialis for impotence cialis generic softtabs cialis generique achat cialis pills generic viagra cialis propecia viagra cialis st flomax cialis generic cialis pills and generic viagra generic viagra cialis pills generic viagra generic cialis pills overnight cheap cialis viagra cialis pregnancy cialis recreational cialis suppliers of cialis in uk cialis on line australia cialisis cialis canadian purchase cialis viagra sales purchase brand cialis buying cialis without a prescription cialis canada and paypal cialis peru cialis 10mg generic cialis legal online before after pictures of viagra best deal viagra brand viagra without prescription buy cheap online prescription viagra buy discount online viagra buy overseas viagra buy viagra australian caverta generic for viagra caverta generic viagra cheap online order viagra cheap online pharmacy viagra viagra consultation online viagra delivery online overnight viagra description viagra doesnt viagra work dole viagra effects viagra woman generic overnight shipping viagra generic viagra buy sildenafil citrate generic viagra soft tab gloria viagra i-doser viagra indication viagra kamagra uk viagra l arginine with viagra men taking viagra no online order prescription viagra online consultation viagra overnight delivery generic viagra stars and viagra purchase viagra soft tabs uk viagra kamagra viagra indication viagra online in united states viagra soft tab generic viagra u s pharmacies viagra viagra online cheap pharmacy were to buy viagra buying viagra online to australia buy viagra without perscription brand viagra without a prescription buy viagra au viagra buy in melbourne for sale viagra australia where to buy viagra in melbourne tax viagra viagra in budapest generic viagra free shipping. buy viagra without prescription canada acheter viagra canada buy viagra in melbourne brand name viagra buy buy viagra from melbourne buying viagra online - australia order cheap viagra online viagra for recreation viagra clinic walgreen viagra price how to take kamagra kamagra oral jelly buy online buy kamagra online cheap kamagra kaufen online where is kamagra legal kamagra manufacturer kamagra buy online uk kamagra jelly forum kamagra how to take when to take kamagra kamagra next day delivery uk kamagra europa uk kamagra next day delivery kamagra apotheke kamagra next day delivery in uk kamagra cost buy kamagra cheap online buy kamagra online uk kamagra oral jelly shop buy cheap kamagra online bijwerkingen kamagra kamagra when to take kamagra work buy kamagra oral jelly online kamagra uk next day delivery kamagra jelly forum 2 chainz viagra lyrics husband on viagra retail viagra price viagra koupit viagra tax acheter du viagra sur le net generic viagra compared to viagra viagra online order canada how to buy viagra online safely precio de viagra en mexico viagra duration effect best online pharmacy viagra no prescription viagra sale websites to buy viagra why is viagra expensive pfizer viagra in india medicare cover viagra no prescription viagra online pharmacy poppers y viagra joomla viagra cheap generic viagra in canada buy viagra beijing cheapest viagra online place to buy viagra best prices for viagra online viagra and warfarin anyone tried viagra what happens if a women take viagra fda female viagra cost viagra usa side effects of viagra in women seit wann gibt es viagra what is average cost of viagra instant viagra ice and viagra viagra with meals what are the side effects of viagra for women was passiert wenn eine frau viagra nimmt buy viagra vancouver viagra kaufen usa viagra com red bull viagra und bluthochdruck natural viagra men viagra canada drugs cost of viagra in usa if women take viagra what happens how to buy viagra in nz purchase of viagra tablets viagra god real viagra cheap viagra average cost comprar viagra en chile el viagra lo venden sin receta what happen if women take viagra buy viagra cheap in canada is buying viagra online safe viagra se necesita receta cost of viagra in us best viagra websites como se usa la viagra viagra prices at cvs cs viagra viagra w aptekach come acquistare viagra viagra with red bull how to buy viagra in malaysia effet secondaire viagra viagra with alcohol side effects sustituto de viagra price of cialis in australia cialis venezuela cialis como usar cialis online stores buy generic cialis online cheap cialis in australia price cialis generic europe cialis costs at walmart cialis cost cvs cialis generic does it work como comprar cialis sin receta cialis purchase with paypal buy cheapest cialis online cialis prescription needed prezzo cialis 20 mg walgreens price for cialis cialis 5 mg generic cialis advil purchase cialis us what is the generic for cialis 5 mg cialis with lisinopril buy cialis online cheapest cialis tadalafilo u. s. overnight viagra pfizerviagra order viagra in australia rx pharmacy viagra young people viagra viagra delivery to canada viagra where to buy in malaysia significado levitra after levitra levitra fedex buy levitra online pharmacy online levitra generic price levitrabuy levitra overnight delivery levitra buy levitra online without prescription levitra overnight delivery' levitra buy usa kamagra information kamagra facebook kamagra man kamagra oral jelly in uk kamagra erfahrungsberichte viagra como se usa buy viagra online with mastercard viagra india safe buying viagra us viagra online reliable purchase viagra overnight viagra ultimate shops that sell viagra viagra in usa kaufen viagra usa order effet secondaire de viagra como comprar viagra en madrid viagra cost in usa where can i buy viagra in chennai viagra doctor online cheapest viagra pills canada drugs viagra viagra rx canada what is the best natural viagra viagra uk online no prescription viagra online purchase usa viagra meals what is the viagra challenge como se usa o viagra viagra athletes have viagra for women order viagra overnight viagra ohne rezept online kaufen viagra and eyes viagra sklep como comprar viagra en chile viagra for sale in the usa side effects of viagra on women revatio viagra viagra bei bluthochdruck viagra real cheap active ingredients of viagra viagra em jovens viagra canadian prices cipla viagra generic viagra buy nz viagra cost us viagra schweiz bestellen viagra in women side effects viagra .99 erectial disfunction erictile dysfunction buying lortabs online buy ativan cheap zocor cholesterol buy zocor online order lipitor online buy cheap lipitor buy lipitor cheap viagra online ohne rezept kaufen grupa viagra price viagra insurance viagra instant viagra tablet price india ibuprofen and viagra viagra skin viagra soft tabs online online viagra reliable viagra jovens red bull with viagra viagra at lloyds pharmacy viagra price with insurance venta de viagra chile viagra for the mind buying viagra online canada online viagra no prescription uk medicament le viagra how much is viagra on prescription viagra healthy male viagra norway viagra for sale for women viagra alcohol side effects generic viagra next day delivery viagra supplier uk viagra list price efectos de la viagra en las mujeres before and after viagra photos buy viagra professional online viagra online uk no prescription viagra tablet for men is sildenafil the same as viagra cheap viagra with mastercard compare online viagra prices efectos del viagra en mujeres how to get viagra without doctor online viagra fast delivery efectos del viagra en una mujer viagra in panama viagra original online how long can you take viagra for viagra ii viagra pfizer buy online forum where to buy generic viagra viagra bez recepta viagra and blue vision when to take viagra pill buy viagra online with a mastercard viagra 1000 passiert wenn frau viagra nimmt buying online viagra is it safe alprazolam and viagra how much is viagra 100mg viagra online in ireland where to buy viagra malaysia viagra for athletes viagra valtrex viagra nz online viagra precisa de receita para comprar buy generic viagra in india is viagra a prescription medicine viagra anonymous viagra efectos en la mujer viagra with ibuprofen efectos de viagra en la mujer viagra online doctor get viagra samples taking viagra when young how much is a viagra prescription viagra and women side effects efectos viagra mujer online viagra pharmacy no prescription what happens if women take viagra american generic viagra online viagra ireland viagra red bull viagra pill sale posologie du viagra viagra online original how to buy viagra in chennai where to buy viagra malaysia viagra for athletes viagra valtrex viagra nz online viagra precisa de receita para comprar buy generic viagra in india is viagra a prescription medicine viagra anonymous viagra efectos en la mujer viagra with ibuprofen efectos de viagra en la mujer viagra online doctor get viagra samples taking viagra when young how much is a viagra prescription viagra and women side effects efectos viagra mujer online viagra pharmacy no prescription what happens if women take viagra american generic viagra online viagra ireland viagra red bull viagra pill sale posologie du viagra viagra online original how to buy viagra in chennai should i buy viagra online viagra alternative prescription alcohol viagra side effects what are the active ingredients in viagra viagra online fast delivery sample viagra online viagra advil does viagra help for premature ejaculation no prescription viagra online uk viagra for women tablets viagra mujeres efecto buy viagra from a canadian pharmacy viagra generico on line cost of viagra usa viagra en mujeres efectos viagra crack viagra tablets pakistan generic viagra by cipla viagra forums uk where to buy viagra nz viagra no prescription us viagra cost with insurance viagra online pharmacy no prescription where to buy viagra in malaysia sales cheap viagra women viagra side effects is buying online viagra safe does viagra help in premature ejaculation percocet and viagra viagra side effects for women como se vende el viagra viagra for women sale price of viagra tablet in india south african viagra what is the use of viagra tablets viagra no prescription online uk red bull com viagra viagra hatasai buy generic viagra from india use of viagra tablets generic viagra 2012 viagra in drinks viagra without erectile dysfunction viagra tablets how to use brand viagra canada vardenafil versus viagra viagra and ice generic viagra from cipla sale viagra usa viagra usa 100mg viagra pharmacie sans ordonnance compra de viagra en argentina revatio and viagra se necesita receta para el viagra ibuprofen viagra poppers et viagra drugs similar to viagra cheap viagra pfizer viagra 4 you viagra for women side effects how much is a prescription for viagra get viagra without doctor generic viagra cheap canada viagra malaysia buy how safe is buying viagra online viagra de 5 mg how much is viagra with a prescription how long before to take viagra women and viagra side effects gli effetti del viagra buying viagra in the us how to buy pfizer viagra online find generic viagra blue vision from viagra buy cheap viagra canada online viagra uk no prescription viagra y red bull how to order viagra in australia viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie where can i buy viagra in vancouver side effects from viagra and alcohol the rock viagra buy viagra malaysia purchase viagra tablets onde comprar viagra barato when can viagra go generic effetto del viagra cost of viagra with insurance buying viagra usa long term effect viagra viagra sale women viagra pfizer canada viagra lilly online doctor viagra viagra and alcohol side effects viagra mit red bull brand viagra in canada viagra kupit how young to take viagra viagra posologie american viagra online alcohol effect on viagra viagra and red bull componente del viagra buying viagra in canada online efecto del viagra en las mujeres viagra loss of hearing viagra in edmonton overnight viagra u.s grand viagra viagra overnight us generic viagra pay with paypal viagra und red bull viagra online legitimate order viagra pill viagra bluthochdruck pfizer viagra buy online viagra alternative forum the best natural viagra drug interaction with viagra venta viagra chile viagra comprar barato viagra soft 100 what shops sell viagra how was viagra developed why to use viagra tablets venta viagra en chile viagra 100mg tabs where can i buy viagra in malaysia percocet viagra viagra precos buy viagra no prescription cheap viagra nz buy usa viagra kaufen efectos viagra en la mujer alcohol and viagra side effects cost of pfizer viagra reliable viagra online staxyn and viagra viagra la femei best prices generic viagra how does viagra help with premature ejaculation where to buy viagra in germany viagra for bodybuilding how to take a viagra pill buy viagra online pfizer buy viagra chennai viagra tablets sale viagra joomla viagra ointment viagra generic next day delivery side effects of viagra and alcohol viagra for fertility buy viagra ny viagra en la mujer efectos active ingredients viagra niagara viagra viagra is contraindicated with what viagra video clips buying viagra from canada online canada viagra drugs viagra buy malaysia average cost for viagra efectos de la viagra en la mujer viagra supplier in uk viagra venta chile use of viagra pills viagra canada rx viagra in adelaide how long can you take viagra efecto del viagra en mujeres viagra rapid viagra and percocet viagra photos before and after where to buy viagra in vancouver viagra online for men price of viagra with insurance effect of viagra on young men how to work viagra for men alternative viagra uk pfizer viagra canada how much is prescription viagra viagra tablet price in india viagra cost usa where to buy generic viagra forum is online viagra legitimate healthy male viagra durex with viagra how much is viagra prescription buy viagra canadian pharmacy viagra cost insurance viagra alprazolam viagra precoz viagra toys como comprar viagra barato viagra effect on young men viagra generico italia viagra bulgaria viagra revatio online viagra overnight shipping side effects of viagra for women efectos viagra en mujeres addiction au viagra what is the use of viagra pills brand viagra from canada best online viagra prices compare viagra prices online viagra sale pharmacy active ingredients in viagra how often to take viagra viagra and heart attacks buy viagra pfizer online what effects does viagra have cheap viagra generic canada cheap generic viagra from canada how many viagra should i take side effects of viagra with alcohol free viagra no prescription viagra for men online compra viagra contrareembolso viagra kaufen in usa take viagra how long before canadian pharmacy to buy viagra how much is a prescription of viagra viagra in glasgow viagra delivery canada buy viagra from canadian pharmacy viagra cheap real viagra 5 mg viagra pill 100 viagra pills 100 mg viagra no erectile dysfunction viagra effect on females side effects of female viagra viagra cvs cost pfizer viagra in canada free viagra pill online viagra europe buy generic viagra forum viagra jersey can i buy viagra in canada over the counter cost of viagra cvs buy viagra in nz effect of alcohol on viagra viagra online ohne rezept bestellen viagra side effects with alcohol male and female viagra viagra side effects video viagra wirkungseintritt how long before take viagra como se usa el viagra biverkningar viagra viagra to lower blood pressure viagra prescription much acquisto viagra on line viagra generic 2012 crack and viagra cheapest viagra online place buy viagra why would women take viagra acheter viagra pfizer alprazolam viagra generic viagra sites buy viagra cheap no prescription red bull y viagra buy cheap viagra no prescription viagra adelaide cheap generic viagra canada online viagra nz what happens when females take viagra sildenafil same viagra best site to get viagra purchase viagra mastercard is there women viagra are there viagra for women what was viagra developed for best prices viagra online viagra cost in us sign up for viagra when to take a viagra pill viagra similar drugs viagra e viagra generico viagra bestellen schweiz viagra make you bigger viagra with warfarin poppers and viagra viagra journal side effects of viagra video is viagra over the counter in australia viagra prescription sample viagra effects on females diovan and viagra viagra kaufen in den usa storage of viagra pill for women viagra comprar viagra madrid viagra kuwait buying viagra online is it safe what happens when you use viagra purchase viagra with mastercard viagra on sale in usa super viagra canada side effects of alcohol and viagra cheap viagra real who developed viagra viagra side effects how long viagra from lloyds pharmacy viagra acquisto on line viagra over the counter australia where can i buy viagra nz viagra from india is it safe viagra in den usa kaufen viagra und poppers alprazolam y viagra viagra tablets what for use purchase viagra 100mg compra de viagra contrareembolso how much is viagra with prescription lilly viagra buy viagra in chennai real viagra for cheap how long to take viagra before viagra album acquistare viagra senza ricetta viagra in cancun que es parecido al viagra purchase real viagra online viagra without insurance viagra in norway effet secondaire du viagra efectos del viagra en la mujer female using viagra viagra generique achat side effects viagra women how to buy viagra in beijing viagra vision blue buying viagra forum viagra side effects on women viagra apotheek the effect of viagra on young men viagra sale in u s a how many times with viagra viagra photos - before and after long term side effects viagra is viagra safe from india the viagra challenge what is the average cost of viagra viagra 100mg usa effect of viagra on females original viagra online viagra sale usa viagra drinks viagra generika bestellen de buy cialis in europe best price for cialis online cheap/discount cialis generic cialis versus cialis cialis brand vs generic where can i buy real cialis como usar o cialis cialis price in australia best results with cialis is a prescription needed for cialis cialis soft uk purchase cialis paypal best cialis price online cialis 20 dosage cialis price at walgreens cialis tablet price cialis and weight loss cialis en suisse 20 mg cialis dosage buy cialis online cheapest cialis tadalafilo 20 mg cialis online cialis price discount generic cialis canada online cost cialis cvs como usar el cialis cialis filmtabletten 20mg comprar cialis espana cialis bijsluiter canadian pharmacy generic cialis best site to buy cialis faq cialis compare cialis online costo del cialis buy cialis generic online cheap cialis vegas definition of cialis costo di cialis cialis 20mg filmtabletten buy cialis 5 mg cialis best results generic cialis from europe how does generic cialis work best online cialis price cialis cost per pill cost of cialis per pill cialis 20 mg online comprar cialis sin receta pharmacy india cialis cialis application cialis overseas cialis in females como usar cialis when does cialis not work cialis espanol bijsluiter cialis buy female cialis walgreens cialis price buy cialis soft cheap cialis brand price cialis walgreens price cialis uk pharmacy cvs cialis cost cialis from usa pharmacy buy cialis tablets cialis generico de india cialis expiry cialis farmacia on line best generic cialis prices cialis function cialis preis 5 mg 10mg or 20mg cialis super cialis cheap buy cialis brand name cialis tablets to buy cialis buy europe get cialis no prescription cialis 5 mg in farmacia indications for cialis order cialis professional indian generic cialis que es mejor cialis o sildenafil why cialis does not work cialis 2 5mg canadian generic cialis pharmacy forum cialis 20 5 mg generic cialis generic cialis canadian pharmacy cheapest cialis 20 mg cialis pills price cialis 10 mg generic generic cialis best prices faq about cialis best site buy cialis cialis packungsbeilage cialis pharmacy india strength of cialis drinking on cialis cialis wellbutrin cialis de lilly icos cialis work on women cialis tablets buy vendita cialis on line best results for cialis cialis vendita on line cialis purchase paypal online generic cialis canada uk cialis prices cialis from boots function of cialis como conseguir cialis cialis paypal kaufen cialis 20mg 4 generic vs brand cialis cialis generic online canada cialis price comparisons symptoms of cialis wellbutrin and cialis cialis what strength wellbutrin cialis usage du cialis canada generic cialis online cialis mit paypal kaufen cialis versus generic cialis cialis canada cheapest cialis en ligne canada generic indian cialis where to get cialis in bangkok cialis online best price buy cialis from europe cialis females cialis at boots generic cialis does work expiration date for cialis buy cialis from mexico get cialis canada generic cialis does it work best prices cialis generic cialis sales online how to get cialis in canada cialis online pharmacy no prescription cialis do you need prescription best price on cialis online cialis bester preis dosage of cialis 20 mg cialis online cost cialis 10mg or 20mg cialis and medicare cialis in chinese cialis 10mg oder 20mg expiration date of cialis cialis pharmacy uk lisinopril with cialis cialis costs walmart cialis deals cialis reviews user price cialis walgreens cialis doctors cialis and advil cialis generic online from canada where to buy cialis in mexico cialis hard on price of cialis per pill user reviews of cialis cialis portal cialis tabletki best prices generic cialis does the generic cialis work wellbutrin with cialis expiration date cialis cialis kaufen mit paypal cialis 20 mg prezzo drinking with cialis is a prescription required for cialis cialis to last longer farmaci generici cialis cialis uk prices expiration date on cialis cialis generic canada online la pastilla levitra levitra 20mg generic prix levitra en pharmacie is levitra over the counter over the counter levitra buy levitra in usa free trial levitra levitra and blood pressure generic levitra no prescription bayer levitra 20 where to buy levitra online no prescription best buy for levitra free levitra trial levitra for men levitra free samples generic levitra in india price of levitra at walmart levitra buy online no prescription levitra aus holland pastilla de levitra levitra generic no prescription levitra free trial prix de levitra en pharmacie price for levitra at walmart que es la pastilla levitra best buy levitra levitra walmart price levitra nedir prix du levitra en pharmacie levitra canada pharmacy levitra price at walmart pharmacy canada levitra walmart price for levitra levitra italia everyday viagra free viagra consultation free viagra on line gay viagra sex generic brands of viagra online generic cialis 10 mg generic pack viagra generic sample viagra generic viagra online without prescription hearing loss viagra herbal viagra review how much for viagra prescription how old to take viagra how viagra effects women side effects is there a viagra for women key viagra mdma viagra message board viagra name cheap viagra nasal viagra online viagra drugs original online viagra over dose viagra overseas cialis paypal accepted viagra poppers as viagra pump with viagra q buy viagra real viagra without a prescription research cialis rx canada viagra samples viagra cialis side effects on viagra for women supplier uk viagra uk alternative viagra uk viagra supplier viagra bigger penis viagra building viagra buy germany viagra canada review viagra cheap free shipping viagra cialas viagra cialis for ed viagra contraindicated viagra drug interaction viagra eyes viagra fertility viagra free gratis viagra free pill viagra homeopathic viagra horas viagra how long side effects viagra ibuprofen viagra in bulgaria viagra in morning viagra large viagra long term side-effects viagra milligrams viagra no prescription required viagra on line store viagra online best prices viagra online without prescription uk viagra paypal no prescription viagra poppers viagra ring viagra rx pharmacy viagra supplier in the uk viagra theme viagra torrent viagra viagra buy search find viagra viagra drug interaction viagra without a precription viagra without a prescription legal viagra without prescription australia viagra wp warfarin viagra where to buy viagra in ny who manufactures viagra cialis research cialis and orgasm cialis advertisements cheapest cialis with prescription cialis 32 approval cialis buy cialis by mail buy cialis softtabs buy softtabs cialis cheap cialis tadalafil cialis and wellbutrin cialis multiple cialis online pill cialis or super viagra cialis pill online cialis prescribing cialis program generic cialis indian marketing cialis opinions on generic cialis viagra cialis prescription online cialis without perscription cialis generic 10 mg cialis generic online uk does generic cialis work order cialis online generic buy cheap generic cialis online generic cialis order online costa rica cialis cheapest cialis canada cialis doesn't work new york cialis cialis without prescription overnight a natural viagra for men average cost of viagra bigger penis with viagra buy deal viagra buying viagra in u s cheap viagra from pfizer cheapest viagra on line drug interaction viagra generic brands viagra online generic generic viagra tadalafil generic shop viagra generic viagra tadalafil heart attacks viagra mdma and viagra meltabs viagra men using viagra next day delivery generic viagra order viagra 1 overcounter viagra pill sale viagra pre-mature ejaculation viagra rapid viagra sample generic viagra success of viagra supplements viagra tadalafil generic viagra topamax viagra viagra alternate viagra and cialas viagra blocker viagra cap viagra find sites free viagra injection viagra oregon viagra over dose viagra overnight in usa viagra pic viagra question viagra quick prescription viagra travel viagra uk news viagra uk supplier viagra without precription viagra in australia without prescription viagra without a prescription australia pfizerviagra viagra professional buy online sellers of viagra viagra without prescription in australia generic viagra with master card viagra buy in nz viagra online sample cheapgenericviagra over counter viagra in australia buy viagra cheap without prescription free viagra sales where to buy viagra germany kamagra 50mg kamagra uk pay with paypal kamagra scams oral jelly kamagra review kamagra how does it work tania kamagra oral jelly kamagra uk kamagra quick uk kamagra cheapest online kamagra is it safe comprare kamagra kamagra polo kamagra aus thailand cheap generic kamagra kamagra cheap generic kamagra pay with paypal uk kamagra health cheapest kamagra online how safe is kamagra the kamagra man kamagra jelly effects kamagra does it work kamagra for men acheter du viagra pfizer www viagra canada drugs fast delivery viagra online viagra sample online order viagra from usa chinese herb viagra generic viagra pay paypal viagra order australia santa viagra viagra tablets women buy viagra cheap canada viagra et poppers does viagra help with ejaculation female viagra tablets viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance how to buy viagra in germany viagra in belgium why use viagra tablet viagra buy perth how much is generic viagra buy 50 mg viagra how does viagra work on men viagra poland pfizer patent viagra viagra aus spanien viagra generico nombre viagra over the counter in usa where to buy viagra over the counter uk instructions to use viagra viagra uk 100mg viagra tablets india price viagra coupon free viagra in atlanta viagra shanghai hydrocodone viagra viagra with antidepressants foods that are natural viagra vimax es viagra viagra muadili viagra caseiro how soon to take viagra venta de viagra en capital generic brand of viagra online viagra in 24 hours viagra israel viagra in san francisco super viagra reviews cheapest viagra net nombre de viagra generico viagra pune viagra pfizer 50 mg cheapest viagra 100mg side effects of viagra for young men side effects generic viagra viagra price in rupees one a day viagra safe viagra from canada viagra bestellen mit paypal is there female viagra buy female viagra in uk when not to use viagra pharmacy selling viagra cheapest viagra online in uk viagra for men dosage viagra works best when how to enhance viagra can viagra help with premature ejaculation viagra in rome free viagra in australia viagra pentru femei directions for use of viagra viagra eyaculacion precoz viagra sales in canada pot and viagra nombre generico del viagra cialis use by women cialis naturale acheter du cialis sur internet cialis aus deutschland bestellen cialis effects on men cialis what does it look like cialis cost at walgreens pfizer cialis regular cialis cialis priser safe to buy cialis online prezzo cialis generico cialis 20mg how to take cialis en la mujer cialis usa price buy cialis pay paypal cialis from canadian pharmacy no prescription is viagra from canada safe viagra for sale us free samples by mail of viagra levitra for erection alternative levitra ad levitra levitra canada prescription levitra cost low cost levitra low levitra online us levitra pack sample levitra what is it used for online levitra us levitra online canadian low prices on levitra levitracheap canada cheap levitra kamagra gel forum oral jelly kamagra forum kamagra from china kamagra news kamagra holland canadian viagra order viagra dosage men mechanism of action of viagra viagra hormone age for taking viagra generic viagra - lowest prices generic soft viagra online viagra store in india is viagra over the counter in usa achat de viagra pfizer viagra generic side effects viagra goedkoop viagra zonder recept kopen viagra nombre generico lowest generic viagra prices viagra kolkata side effects of viagra in young men how does viagra looks like viagra online pharmacy us buying viagra internet viagra legal usa viagra bd where can i buy viagra over the counter in the uk getting a viagra prescription viagra online eu viagra side effects young men viagra ship canada viagra l arginine real viagra canada where to order viagra for women generic viagra tablet viagra indian store what was viagra originally for can viagra make you bigger best ways to take viagra when is the best time to take viagra viagra when to take it for the best results uk pharmacy viagra online is viagra going generic peyronie y viagra where to buy female viagra uk achat de viagra en pharmacie can you purchase viagra over the counter in canada buy viagra yahoo viagra and crestor buy viagra 50 mg como comprar viagra por internet wine and viagra what does viagra do to guys precio de venta de viagra apple viagra what does viagra do for a man viagra same day what not to take with viagra where to buy legitimate viagra try viagra free indian tablets for viagra real viagra in canada viagra or extenze erectyle disfunction online pharmacy overnight delivery viagra does it make you bigger instructions for the use of viagra buy female viagra uk do you need prescription to buy viagra viagra dc viagra fast uk nepal viagra discount viagra in canada safe viagra canada finding viagra viagra mercedes price of viagra in rupees highest dose of viagra viagra muadil getting the best results from viagra viagra canada real viagra utilizzo viagra with wine can i order viagra online cheapest viagra uk online is sildenafil as good as viagra viagra names in india viagra in nepal viagra frankreich us pharmacy viagra online cheap super active viagra viagra for men how does it work buy viagra gel getting prescription for viagra viagra rates in india claritin viagra what is the best time to take viagra viagra side effects forum generic viagra online forum buy viagra oral jelly viagra pill for men dung thuoc viagra can you buy viagra over the counter canada buy viagra in uk over the counter buy viagra dubai can you buy viagra over the counter in canada viagra kvinder viagra birmingham vente de viagra sans ordonnance is viagra from canada safe comment se procurer du viagra viagra la pela vendita viagra generico viagra pills cheap online viagra ecuador viagra columbia buy viagra original timing of viagra viagra natural feminino viagra canada discount viagra pharmacy buying viagra mexico new zealand viagra online where can i buy viagra locally viagra instructions use viagra pramil viagra 100 mg precio getting viagra prescription viagra side effects in young men viagra kick in use of viagra tablet nombre del viagra generico does viagra work for men can you buy viagra over counter canada viagra bestellen zonder recept when is viagra most effective blood pressure medication viagra viagra generic patent where to get viagra in kuala lumpur good viagra online viagra books viagra rome female viagra uk buy historia del viagra can you get viagra prescription impacts of viagra viagra for men cost how does viagra work for men viagra online us pharmacy viagra kick in use of viagra tablet nombre del viagra generico does viagra work for men can you buy viagra over counter canada viagra bestellen zonder recept when is viagra most effective blood pressure medication viagra viagra generic patent where to get viagra in kuala lumpur good viagra online viagra books viagra rome female viagra uk buy historia del viagra can you get viagra prescription impacts of viagra viagra for men cost how does viagra work for men viagra online us pharmacy what will happen if women take viagra el viagra y la eyaculacion precoz avodart and viagra alcohol and viagra use trial packs viagra dj viagra viagra group russian viagra ricetta medica viagra and wine viagra ship from canada how to take viagra tablet 100mg viagra dosage el viagra y la prostata buying viagra on internet viagra colour kinds of viagra take viagra best results buy chinese viagra viagra with steroids viagra sale india can i buy viagra in mexico viagra hydrocodone viagra prescrizione medica viagra over internet viagra online lowest price do you need a prescription to buy viagra viagra canada need prescription viagra safe canada viagra and extenze viagra aus polen mechanism of viagra action does viagra really works viagra sale in india viagra delhi price precio viagra 100 mg viagra in urdu does viagra affect women where can i buy viagra yahoo viagra ayurveda females using viagra viagra best time to take buy cheap viagra from india costo de la viagra en mexico viagra local pharmacy viagra gel buy acheter du viagra sans prescription viagra at work video viagra with blood pressure medication how to take viagra 100mg viagra de cuba how to ask for viagra uk online pharmacy viagra prix du viagra generique best time take viagra united pharmacy viagra viagra in uk shops viagra price delhi viagra kaufen pillen getting viagra on prescription pfizer viagra prescription viagra costo mexico viagra uk online pharmacy viagra kokemuksia costo viagra generico buy viagra pakistan viagra bayer dosage for viagra 100mg viagra von bayer viagra stati uniti obat kuat viagra usa viagra canadian order viagra online shopping in india pfizer viagra achat viagra canada reviews the best time to take viagra viagra east viagra uk shops viagra online shopping india what is the street value of viagra natural viagra in foods purchasing viagra in the uk viagra tablets price in india viagra from canada reviews o que e o viagra viagra how often can i take viagra dla pan viagra online new zealand viagra email spam alternative uses for viagra order viagra by phone viagra others viagra generic medicine how to buy viagra in uk over the counter viagra prescription europe viagra abroad viagra buy pakistan price of viagra tablets in india viagra san francisco where to buy viagra dubai teva viagra blue pills viagra viagra in boots uk where to buy viagra in pakistan does viagra makes you bigger how to buy viagra in dubai viagra 100mg how long order viagra phone blue viagra pills what is turkish viagra when should viagra be taken take viagra with alcohol buying pfizer viagra cheapest canadian viagra viagra 50 mg pfizer viagra one a day viagra and pot side effects of viagra on young men viagra valencia us online pharmacy viagra crestor and viagra viagra directions to use viagra in ayurveda how to take viagra tablets how hard is it to get viagra dosage of viagra for men viagra before after pics viagra pharmacy australia viagra and augmentin side effects viagra young men australian generic viagra extenze or viagra blogs on generic viagra where to buy non prescription viagra viagra professional 100 mg viagra kaufen nachnahme viagra femenino comprar what is the use of viagra tablet viagra atlanta nombre generico de viagra 50 mg viagra online best way get viagra viagra tablet how to use buy viagra over the counter uk viagra boots uk viagra canadian pharmacy no prescription viagra pill bottle viagra aus der natur viagra us pharmacy online top viagra sites american pharmacy viagra viagra when you don't need it the discovery of viagra free coupons for viagra viagra ru trial 2 what is the average price of viagra swiss viagra who pays for viagra seroquel and viagra viagra feminino natural where can you buy viagra yahoo discount viagra from canada what is viagra in urdu viagra en cuba online shopping of viagra in india what colour is viagra viagra hard sell viagra de bayer viagra pharmacy reviews get viagra at a discount best place for generic viagra dosage of viagra 100mg viagra in shops uk viagra in shanghai where to buy viagra perth free viagra offer viagra pills work viagra pics before and after when not to take viagra 100mg viagra uk how to consume viagra how often can take viagra mechanism of action viagra where to buy viagra in uk over the counter viagra robin williams how to buy viagra in perth viagra der natur viagra american pharmacy acquisto viagra italia viagra costo en mexico viagra online uk cheapest viagra on steroids free viagra email can i buy viagra in usa viagra size increase viagra shops in uk viagra emails spam professional viagra uk viagra in israel can viagra affect women cost of viagra for men boots uk viagra free samples of viagra by mail over the counter viagra in the usa viagra saudi arabia viagra boston doctor to prescribe viagra can viagra help premature ejaculation costo viagra en mexico generic viagra difference viagra twitter how should viagra be taken viagra 100mg uk generic viagra patent viagra at altitude viagra splitter viagra edad online viagra us pharmacy order viagra mastercard online shopping viagra india purchasing viagra from canada how to take 100mg viagra benadryl viagra pfizer viagra kaufen crestor viagra viagra family finasteride and viagra viagra kinds viagra satin al viagra online uk pharmacy viagra offices viagra nigeria achat viagra pharmacie viagra for sale in india buy viagra super active online viagra veny nelkul viagra swiss viagra and altitude buying viagra on the internet over the counter viagra usa herbal viagra forum viagra in bd viagra free coupon costo de viagra en mexico viagra de 100 mg precio pfizer patent on viagra what are the side effects of generic viagra viagra directions use viagra directions of use free viagra coupons viagra seroquel order viagra plus achat viagra sans ordonnance viagra other drugs viagra in cuba is viagra legal in the uk viagra from uk pharmacies canadian generic viagra online viagra for sale india israel viagra duracion de la viagra viagra finasteride get viagra online uk viagra young men side effects viagra store india can viagra cure premature ejaculation average price for viagra buy viagra uk over counter tablet viagra use where can you buy viagra over the counter in uk viagra for sale in us viagra samples free mail does viagra cure premature ejaculation where can i buy viagra in dubai buy viagra over the counter in the uk comprar viagra en espana viagra tablets in india price viagra plus online does viagra actually work components of viagra when viagra should be taken viagra tablets price india viagra instructions how to use viagra no prescription canadian pharmacy getting a prescription for viagra where can i buy viagra in the uk over the counter us viagra online pharmacy viagra action mechanism buy non prescription viagra viagra side effects on young men Documentary Editing 31 (2010)
Reviews of "The Papers of Abraham Lincoln: Legal Documents and Cases"

Documentary Editing 31 (2010)

Reveiwed by Anthony M. Joseph, Houston Baptist University

The Papers of Abraham Lincoln: Legal Documents and Cases.  Edited by Daniel W. Stowell, Susan Krause, John A. Lupton, Stacy Pratt McDermott, Christopher A. Schnell, Dennis E. Suttles, Kelley B. Clausing, and R. Dan Monroe.  Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2008.  4-volume boxed set.  2,328 pages.  Illustrations. Cloth 978-0-8139-2606-3.  $300.00.

A REVIEW    Anthony M. Joseph

Lincoln's long career as a lawyer has been as much the subject of winsome anecdote as comprehensive scholarly study---an unhappy balance caused in part by the lack of readily accessible documents bearing on his practice.  That problem, however, was remedied in stunning fashion with the publication in 2000 of the massive digital edition of Lincoln's legal papers, The Law Practice of Abraham Lincoln (LPAL).  The LPAL produced more than 96,000 searchable documents spanning over 5,000 cases and nearly 500 nonlitigation activities through the course of Lincoln's legal career.  The present selective letterpress edition in four volumes continues the same tradition of legal and editorial expertise found in the digital edition.  Together the two editions should help bring about a great leap forward in Lincoln legal scholarship.  With its extensive scholarly apparatus, the letterpress edition in particular provides a unique window onto Lincoln's daily work as a lawyer.

Here, of course, the material is necessarily whittled down.  This edition presents forty-nine cases chose from the digital edition on the basis of "many attributes, including chronology, geography, jurisdiction, subject matter, legal action, the quality of the documentation, the number of Lincoln documents, Lincoln's role, judgment, and, to a lesser extent, the notoriety of the case at the time and since in Lincoln scholarship" (1:xix).  A larger number of cases are given brief treatment over the course of three additional chapters, one covering Lincoln's practice in the Sangamon County Circuit Court during its Spring 1842 term and two covering Lincoln on circuit in 1842 and 1852.  In addition to the cases, the editors have included chapters on Lincoln's views of lawyering, his legal work outside the courtroom, and his work as a court official.  Three appendices explain the structure of the Illinois court system, its pleading and practice, and legal descriptions of land.  A biographical directory, a glossary of legal terms, and an effective index round out the fourth and final volume.  The legal glossary and the appendix on pleading and practice provide an extensive technical introduction to antebellum law.  Properly used, these sections will make the documents vastly more intelligible to readers and researchers alike.  Researchers just beginning their forays into American antebellum legal history, whether as Lincoln scholars, Illinois historians, political historians, or legal historians, will find this technical apparatus of enormous value.

Despite the culling of case materials, this edition is remarkable for its breadth.  The cases illustrate a great variety of areas of law, including debt, bankruptcy, inheritance, divorce, murder, breach of contract, patents, personal injury, taxation, and slander.  Lincoln's work in in different venues is also represented, including the Illinois county circuit courts, the Illinois Supreme Court, and federal circuit and district courts held in Springfield.  This edition also impresses with its unflagging effort to provide biographical, social, and legal background to the cases.  Through commentary, copious annotation, the biographical director, and the legal glossary, the editors have provided readers and researchers with an abundance of material to contextualize Lincoln's role and the legal issues involved.  The degree of biographical detail concerning the litigants as well as the lawyers, judges, and court officers is remarkable.  We learned that Samuel Rogers remarried after securing his divorce (1:48).  We discover that Jane Davidson died just a few months after Lincoln helped the father of her illegitimate child avoid paying her child support (1:398).  Illustrations sprinkle the case narratives.  Sarah Allsop Tennery gazes at us in an 1884 portrait, years after she won her slander case against John Sturgeon for calling Sarah and her sister whores and adulterers (2:160, 1868).  We see the drawing of the "atmospheric churn" at issue in the case of Lewis v. Moffett (1848-50) (2:45) and a diagram of Jonathan Haines's new harvesting machine from the patent infringement case of Rugg v. Haines (3:250).  William Duff Armstrong, accused of murder, and his mother, Hannah Armstrong, who asked Lincoln to defend her son, make their disturbing appearances (4:3, 10, 11).  Illustrations of documents in Lincoln's own hand are strangely absent.  Nonetheless, no reader or researcher will leave these volumes feeling they have encountered materials lacking in sufficient scholarly adornment.

Legal Documents and Cases does include some editorial decisions that merit scrutiny.

The placement of the more substantive biographies at the end of volume four sometimes puts the information at a considerable distance from where the person is actually mentioned.  For example, we first encounter William Florville, "Billy the Barber," on page six in the first volume, and an intriguing photograph of Florville appears on the following page; however, we must turn to volume four, page 349, to read that Florville was a Haitian émigré who became Lincoln's barber in Springfield.  On the other hand, the directory does allow the editors to supply very full accounts of the personages once and for all, without the limitations of space imposed by footnotes.  On balance, one sees more gain than loss in this arrangement, which is of course found in many other documentary editions.

The editors have also published letters in full even where they only partially bear on the case at hand.  In the chapter on James Bell & Company for the Use of Speed v. Hall (1842-43), for example, one of Lincoln's letters to Joshua Speed, running more than two pages long, addresses a number of additional cases as well as political and personal matters (1:256-58).  One wonders whether it might have been appropriate to publish only the portion related to the Bell case.  That raises the question, of course, of where the remainder of the letter could be placed, as the edition does not provide a chapter for Lincoln's general legal correspondence.

Of greater impact on the organization of Legal Documents and Cases is the editors' decision to intersperse a running commentary for each case among its documents.  This method contrasts with the practice of other editions of legal papers, such as the collections for Lord Mansfield, John Adams, Daniel Webster, and the early Supreme Court of the United States, which generally discuss the background to each case in a single, consolidated introduction preceding all the documents.  The running commentary does have the advantage of drawing the reader's eye to surrounding documents.  But the commentary also has the tendency to diminish the impact of valuable scholarly findings, such as the number of each type of case Lincoln tried---information that appears at different points in the commentaries and must be fished out at some inconvenience.  The commentaries also tend to repeat information that the reader has just encountered in the documents themselves.  In Rogers v. Rogers, for example, the judgment indicates that the jury found that Samuel Rogers' wife Polly "has not been guilty of adultery as charged" (1:47).  The editors add in the summary on the very next page that Rogers and his counsel "did not convince the jury that Polly Rogers was guilty of the charge of adultery" (1:48).  Although such repetition sometimes helps the reader understand the gist of difficult documents, it also sometimes makes the commentary appear perfunctory in striking contrast to the other editorial interventions in the edition.  The editors' decision to place their commentary in a larger font than the documents themselves compounds the problem.

Such criticisms, however, do not substantially detract from the overall impression this edition makes.  The legal documents are well chosen and illuminating in surprising ways.  They reveal, first, how varied the work of the antebellum lawyer was.  Lincoln served as a guardian ad litem for minors, as a public prosecutor, and, in more than three hundred cases, as a temporary judge (4:274-75, 280).  He was called upon to serve on at least five writ-of-inquiry juries, which were used to assess damages in cases of default judgments (4:272-73).  In the numerous cases for which he was an attorney, Lincoln propelled litigation forward.  He not only filed pleadings on behalf of his clients, but also drafted jury instructions which he hoped the judge would incorporate into the instructions ultimately delivered to jurors (2:158-59, 169-70, 238, 274-75).  This was not an uncommon maneuver for antebellum lawyers, as the glossary helpfully notes (4:398).  In one case, the famous murder trial of William Armstrong, the judge certainly used Lincoln's proposed instructions, as they were endorsed "given" (4:14-15).  In a breach-of-contract case, by contrast, the judge explicitly refused Lincoln's proposed jury instruction, and after the jury returned a verdict against his client, Lincoln protested the refusal in a succession of filings (3:241-43, 244).  Lincoln also drafted in his own hand a number of decrees and judgments in cases where the decision from the bench was favorable to his client (1:130; 2:85-87, 279-80, 289-90, 300, 348-49; 3:59-60, 63, 187-88; 4:134).  The editors are undoubtedly correct in concluding that these decrees and judgments formally became the decisions of the courts.  Thus when Lincoln, acting as a temporary judge, wrote the judgment in Peabody v. Roney (1852), he was only doing, textually speaking, what he had done as a lawyer in many other cases (4:286).

Even the pleadings themselves prove to be more than mere legal boilerplate dutifully but reluctantly printed.  The seduction case of Grable v. Margrave (1840-42) demonstrates how the pleadings can help fully illuminate the legal significance of a case.  William J. Grable impregnated Melissa Jane Margrave, the unmarried daughter of Thomas Margrave, in 1839.  Rather than sue Grable explicitly for the seduction of his daughter, Thomas Margrave followed the path that common-law pleading offered in such cases.  In his declaration, the first pleading made by the plaintiff in a common-law case, Margrave became not an aggrieved father seeking to vindicate his daughter's honor but instead a "master" harmed by the expenses and loss of service associated with the pregnancy of his "servant" (1:241).  Indeed, the word "seduction" is not even mentioned in the declaration.  Yet Margrave won $300 in damages, less than the amount he sought but more than his stated financial loss.  Hearing the case on appeal in the Illinois Supreme Court, Judge Samuel H. Treat acknowledged that "the loss of service is still the legal foundation of the right to recover" but noted that the common law now permitted the father to recover damages "beyond the mere loss of service" (1:247).  Treat's opinion was already published in the Illinois state reports, but by publishing here both the declaration and the opinion the editors are able to expose the gap between the common law's forms of pleading and its actual rules of decision.

Lincoln himself, of course, emerges from these pages through the case documents he filed as well as in the letters that passed between him and his clients, which are amply represented here.  In his recent work, An Honest Calling: The Law Practice of Abraham Lincoln (2006), Mark E. Steiner, a former associate editor of the LPAL, describes Lincoln as a lawyer who was willing to represent any side in a case and who trusted the legal system to produce a morally acceptable outcome.  These volumes, selective though they are, do convey this impression of Lincoln the lawyer.

The case of Todd v. Ware (1843-44) is instructive.  This was the only case in which Lincoln represented his father-in-law, John [Robert] Todd (1:301).  Lincoln initiated the case for breach of contract in 1843, about one year after marrying Mary Todd and shortly after meeting her father for the first time (1:305).  In 1841 Todd had purchased 243 acres of land from Nathaniel A. Ware, agreeing to make three annual payments for the property in "current Bankable Paper receivable in Deposite at the State Bank of Ills. in Springfield."  In early 1842, however, the State Bank of Illinois failed.  Todd subsequently made two payments in the bank's paper, which Ware accepted, but when in May 1843 he tendered the balance in the same currency, Ware refused to accept it.  By that time the bank's money had depreciated to less than half its face value.  Todd, however, insisted that the agreement permitted payment in depreciated currency and sued Ware for breach of contract.

In the proceedings that followed, Lincoln went to great lengths on his father-in-law's behalf.  When his bill of complaint was successfully challenged for being "argumentative" and otherwise insufficient, he promptly filed an amendment.  He sought unsuccessfully to obtain the notes of debt originally given to Ware.  He deposed three of his own witnesses and cross-examined two of the defendant's.  He filed exceptions to some of the questions the defense had asked of witnesses as well as the witnesses' answers (1:332-33).  He wrote a lengthy brief, one of the few published in this edition (1:328-32).  Ultimately, however, Lincoln's efforts were to no avail.  Judge Samuel H. Treat, in an opinion published here for the first time, determined that the bank's notes were not truly "bankable" at the time Todd tendered payment and that the notes circulated at a forty-to-fifty percent discount in comparison with those of other institutions.  Equity demanded that Todd make his payment in better money than that.

Ultimately, this case does much more than show a lawyer serving his client or a son-in-law helping out his father-in-law.  Lincoln sought to permit a debtor to pay in depreciated money, an action which Federalists had considered patently unjust in the era of the Founding and which continued to vex and dismay Americans in Lincoln's time.  Lincoln's posture in the case is explicable on the premise that Lincoln placed virtually complete trust in the moral efficacy of the legal system and believed that his trust fulfilled his moral responsibility.

Or was Lincoln willing to do for John [Robert] Todd what he was unwilling to do for others?  The Bennett cases suggest otherwise.  Richard Bennett, father of a large family, impregnated Jane Davidson, a woman not his wife.  She sought child support from him.  With Lincoln's help, however, Bennett took advantage of an Illinois statutory provision that released a father from his financial obligation to an illegitimate child if he sought custody of the child and the mother refused to grant it.  In the Illinois Supreme Court, Justice Norman Purple was "reluctantly compelled to admit" that a father who had the "inhumanity" to demand custody of his illegitimate child "in its helpless and dependent infancy" was indeed released from further financial obligation should the mother refuse.  The state legislature revised the law before Purple's opinion was issued, but of course the new provision, which required the father to pay support until the child was three, could not be applied to Bennett.  In short, Lincoln had helped loosen Bennett from any underlying ethical obligation both to mother and child.  When Davidson died a few months after the decision, the editors poignantly note, "the county paid for her casket and burial" (1:398).

Nor was Lincoln inclined to be discriminating in cases with clear political implications.  When the Illinois Central Railroad sought to enjoin two Illinois counties from taxing its land, Lincoln made himself available as counsel for the counties.  When the counties declined, Lincoln offered his services to the railroad, which quickly retained him (2:384).  Ultimately, Lincoln won the case for the railroad and claimed $5,000 for his efforts, the largest legal fee he ever collected (2:410).  When Stephen Douglas later accused Lincoln of representing the railroad to the detriment of the people of Illinois, Lincoln simply explained that the railroad's charter required the company to pay taxes to the state, not the counties, and that the people's interest was served thereby.  He also noted that he had offered his services to the other side and had been declined (2:413-14).  What more need be said?  Any notion that he was "on very cozy terms with the Railroad Company, I do not comprehend," Lincoln offered (2:414).

Lincoln's trust in the legal system, however legitimate, may have masked a lack of zeal for the specific content of the law, whether he saw ethical implications in that content or not.  Over time his cases became more important and his reputation grew, but Lincoln was never beyond being caught flatfooted on legal questions that arose.  In the murder case People v. Harrison, Judge Edward Y. Rice claimed the right to determine the admissibility of dying declarations; Lincoln remarked to his own discredit that he had "never heard of such law" (4:174-75).  In 1860, an indictment drafted by Lincoln was quashed  because of a critical omission.  Ward Hill Lamon, the public prosecutor for whom Lincoln had written the indictment, asked Lincoln for any legal authorities that might be adduced to revive the indictment.  "I will take it as a great favor," Lamon remarked, as "I have more pride in having my Indictments sustained, than in anything else in the practice of law" (4:278).  Lincoln replied vaguely that "Our Statute . . . relaxes the high degree of technical certainty formerly required."  If the indictment remained quashed, Lincoln quipped, "it will only prove that my forte is as a Statesman, rather than as a Prossecutor" (4:279).

Lincoln's errors, indeed, did not seem to faze him.  To be sure, he was careful to protect his reputation.  When his plea in the case of Dungey v. Spencer was successfully challenged by a demurrer, Lincoln exclaimed to the opposing attorneys, "Now, by Jing, I will beat you boys!"  As one opposing attorney later reminisced, Lincoln wanted to redeem himself for having been "demurred out of court" (3:145).  Yet the correspondence published in this edition shows a Lincoln who was remarkably candid---even breezily so---in admitting to doubts, omissions, and errors.  The legal view expressed by a federal marshal in one case "did not occur to me," Lincoln acknowledges to one client (3:221).  He tells another that he "took fright" when he became aware that the statue of limitations might have expired on the client's suit (3:202).  Lincoln states plainly that he "forgot" to pay the taxes on several lots owned by William Florville, "though under promise" to do so (4:258).

Lincoln scholars will mine this edition for new insights into Lincoln's legal temperament, his legal philosophy, and the impact his practice had on his political outlook.  Studies of Lincoln the lawyer have emerged since the LPAL were published, including Steiner's as well as Brain Dirck's Lincoln the Lawyer (2007), but undoubtedly these will not be the last.  Legal Documents and Cases, with its four substantial volumes of material transcribed and contextualized, will encourage scholars to look at Lincoln's law practice afresh.  Previous assessments, some stretching back to the reminiscences of the late nineteenth century, will be influential but not determinative.  Was it trust in the legal system that encouraged Lincoln to rely on America's political system to resolve the sectional dispute?  Was it his regard for legal outcomes that inclined him to expect Southerners to accept the political outcome of the election of 1860?  It is gratifying to know that this edition puts us on a road to answering such questions more effectively and reliably than ever before.

The Association for Documentary Editing, Documentary Editing 31 (2010): 104-10.