[ docketing ]
No. Subscribers to this Petition 630.
To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled:
THE PETITION OF THE UNDERSIGNED, INHABITANTS OF CINCINNATI, AND VICINITY,
Respectfully Showeth,
That they have heard, with much regret, of the introduction of a measure for your Legislative sanction, pregnant with serious and lasting evils, and adverse to the spirit of our Republican Institutions, as well as to the deliberate will of the American People.
This measure, which proposes to give, in fee-simple, an immense portion of our National Territory to a single individual, for the purpose of securing the construction of a Railroad from the waters of Lake Michigan to those of the Pacific Ocean, presents, on the most gigantic scale, and in the most injurious and corrupting form, the odious and Aristocratic features of Land Monopoly.
We believe that the immense grant or sacrifice proposed for the promotion of the Railroad scheme of Mr. Whitney, if sanctioned by our National Legislature, will stand as a lasting monument of our folly, and will bring down upon the supporters of this scheme the severest condemnation of the People.
A measure involving consequences so vast and permanent, should not be adopted without distinctly ascertaining that it is in conformity with the will of the American people. No such expression has yet been given by any very large number of the voters of this Republic; and we feel well satisfied, that, should any candidate for the Chief Magistracy of this country avow himself in favor of thus alienating the Public Domain, the odium and opposition thereby excited would ensure his defeat.
Although the power of thus alienating the Public Domain at present rests in Congress, unrestrained by any clause in the Constitution, we believe that so flagrant an abuse of that power would produce a reaction in the public mind, threatening even the repeal of any such grant, and dangerous to the rights which may be acquired under any such system of partial Legislation, tending to revive in this country the system of Landlord Vassalage which has desolated Ireland, and crushed to the earth the laboring population of Europe.
Not only is the proposed measure contrary to the genius of our Democratic Institutions, and corrupting in its tendency, but, as a measure of National Policy, we object earnestly to a scheme which tends to divert emigration from the National Domain to the lands of any individual or Company. And while we are willing that the beneficent energies of our Government should be exerted in the establishment of National Railroads and works of public benefit, we cannot approve of a precedent so anti-Republican, and destructive in its tendency, as the proposed grant.
Jos. R Buchanan Samuel Lewis
Jos W. Taylor J. W. Piatt
T. V. Morrow E. Yulie
Wm Price Horace K. Varney
L. A Hine Theodore Nye
Chas. Fisher James Burt
P. McGroarty Alex. W. Roup
J. J. Quinn Wm H Decker
G. E. Pugh A [G?]. Battersley
William Morrison Wm A Brooks
Andw M Leslie Jo Wright
T. B. Mary T. Wright
Jas A Murray S. T. Bender
Edward OHare Wm McIntyre
W J Doherty
Wm A. Van Amringe Stephen Nye
W. H. Palmer Wm Clark
Francis Talb Patrick Boyle
James W Stacy Leonard Neumester
Philip Koeniger
Thos E Robinson Charles L Getty
Nelson Gates Valduin Ulinck
Edward S Philips George Bingey
Henry Kenser F S Hauer
Henry Winmann C. Gray
Henry Russe J Konk
Valentine [Anburn?] Georg Son
George Adams Alexander Brown
Samuel McPeake John Bollner
Alfred B Corke Henry [Onege?]
John Finke Daniel Kieffer
Henry Padick Peter Herr
B West J Van fleet H Kramer
[ certification ]
05/15/1848
Having compared the first Sixty five names upon this petition with the original subscriptions thereto in pencil and otherwise I hereby certify that this is a faithful transcript of the original signatures which have been left in my possession.
Jos. R. Buchanan
Robert M Castlan John Clark
Israel Price
Joseph [?] Scharl Mott
T Bergkeger P. W. Ryan
B. [N. Gedehoff?] Andrew Bensing
Ephraim Sparks
Georg Rath R Hall
Karl [Neuhaus?] J F Nordmann
Jakob Kiessling Saml D. Towner
Ludwig Sailz Ferdinand Roltgen
Johann [?] Joseph M Cutler
[Heinrich Laila?] Joseph Wibel
Calvin Walker
Peter Fischer Christ [?]
Peter W. Reinshagen J. P. Evans
Gustav [Hufslerhidt?] P. Smith
F Röhrka Sn Dominik Schwarz
[?] [Nehery?] James R Miller
Heinrich Sachs. Benjamin Hinebach
[Walmden?] [Thyl?] Peter Foy
Betz: [?]
Martin Reichel Samuel Campbell
[Joseph?] [Englart?] John Metz
J Wilhelm Güntmann Charles Abbey
Johann Schoff Wm C. Phillips
J. G. Woelfel Peter. C. Guion
P. Y. Brown
Henry Brüggemann John Crawford
Heinrich Walther H B Katenkamp
James Ganaver
August Hüller. E [Harvie?]
Georg Heitz B. Garmhausen
H Harsh A Keller
J H Gannhausen C. [Monyrich?]
George Klanke W Jaffern
W Pryme L. Hart
J Gray B Schulte
H Rose F Harsch
M. Parker
E Ashley W. H. Dixon
P. Ashley Peter Hummill
James Hyer John W. Coleman
J. N. Towne T. Salter
E. Morton Thos. Jennings
Sml. Jones John T. Baker
Wm Quick Christopher Lee
J. E. Towne Wm Owens
J. Rabb Thomas Donaldson
Benjamin Carroll J. H Windle
Joseph [-?] Thos. H. Walters
Ira Thomasson J H Moore
C. B. Matthews T. J. Wright
Thomas Hays W L McNeil
James Boid E R Roe
M. Parmer A Potter
Jacob Stewart G W Hunt
Wm Prentiss J Hance
R. R. Hopkins Tho J Orley
G W Dickey
N L Van Sandt Geo W Wallace
Thos. L Boucher Chas. C Schell
Jesse Garretson Jos. G. Hunt
M Wilber James O Byrne
A M Stayman Franklin Talbott
J Van Amringe W H McGranagham
R S Newton Danl F Morey
Wm L Marshall Thos D Cooke
[ certification ]
05/15/1848
I hereby certify that the 55 names, upon this page are truly copied from the original subscriptions to the petition against Whitney’s grant
Jos. R Buchanan.

<Page 2>
J. P. Whitcomb J C Walter
Jacob Waggoner J W Brown
Edwin Mattoon Isaac Cummins
W. T. Coggshall J Goslin
David Stoddart C W Kastentine
N. T. Ingersoll J M Wylie
T. L. Kirkup Daniel Finlay
John Van Amringe Edward Brennan
J H Herndon John Smith
C C Crandall Frank Bruce
P Stille J. V. Richardson
Edwin A Lodge L A Smith
Obadiah Prentiss T. Lynch
J H Stevens F. Harris
W. O. Brian
T B Gardner G. N. Frank
William H Jones C. I Moore
Daniel Bukhart B Ashley
John Thorpe G A Smith
E W Tuttle H. I. Dodge
H R Curry William Moffatt
W. Wainwright Henry Clark
A E Smith Augustus R. Hynson
Caleb Carman R. J. Matthews
T. M. Brooks Lawrence Halpin
[ certification ]
05/15/1848
I hereby certify that the fortynine names upon this page are truly copied from the original subscriptions to the petition against Whitney’s grant which are in my possession.
Jos. R Buchanan
James Blinn E S McClellan
Cornelius Rowe
Thos W Kinsey Elihue Greene,
A G Noyes
P. J. Moore S J & A G Noyes
C. F Conwell D B Andrews
P. K. Wombaugh
J: J: Browne Edmd B Blunt
Daniel McGouran Charles Howe
Stephen L. Passel George L Evans
E. B. Smith S. S. Roys
Evan B Carty
Daniel McSwiney A. Kellogg
E Blinn Jr Matthew Simpson
P. P. L. Prince D D Lockwood
O Aldrich J D Parner
J Mann
J W Rich J. B. Russell
S J Orange Wm C [Oriall?]
James Cooper J. F. Taylor.
John P. Donogh H H Van Amringe
R. P. Donogh Bernard Tynan
James B. Donogh A. C. Semple
J Y Lindsay
L. [Repling?] M Lilley
John Shaw John Thompson.
E A Chandler A. H. Baldridge
Geo McGregor William Glenn
Ezekiel Cutter James Whitelock
Wells H. White B. F. Fisk
J H McGeorge Joseph Draper
James [Freel?] Edward Inskip
J A Milot Elias Dudley
Marquis C Winchester William Ryland
Edward Stokes T A. Conway
Stephen Faulkner. Charles Vanpelt
John Darling
Ariel Case. 2d
J S. Dean Chas Munroe
Norman. Collins
M B Mann T. F. Baldwin
M. Sulzbacher Jno B. Cobb
John Elias
D J [Willans?] Charles Woodward
W H Galbraith Wm Dod.
Charles Kelly W D Griffing
T. Nasser Isaac Lyens
M. T. Brockelbank Julius [Deitrich?]
D Dunning.
Wm H Oakley. David Churchill
Th Townsend
M Wallace Justin M. Thatcher
R B Cowles John Cassels Wright
George. G. Walker
R T Goddard Wm Arons
H. Truitt Samuel Boggs
James Inns C C Williams
Rasselar Whitcomb A P Johnston
Jacob Graff C. Moore
Thomas Martin L. H. Schell
R. Cox James Clark
D. Uruer
John Ewing G. Fisher
Joseph Wilson J. B. Covert
John H. Coleman64 J M. Brown
J. L. Vattier B. Wise
A. Pugh
George H, Perrine W. T. Grow
Geo B Rohrer
[F?] James F. Rhodes
Harry R Smith B Archer
W L Hazen G. M. Pickering
Wm Guilford
M Ranney
F. Clark
C. C. Hand Stephen Maxon
B Ludowici A. Smith
Benj F Gossin Jeremiah Trotter
Thomas Pliff William Teardale
E Mallinee
F Henry Eberle D. Roth.
E Hill Eli Honran
Jeremiah D [Garrisen?] Jas, O, Stewart
C Ratcliff D W Long
Levi Parker
T Shortill B Wentworth
J [Pancoast ?] Jr W, Saunders
D F Davis Alexander Paull
J. B. Wolcott Thos Trup
Wm S Lossin A Pharis
Wm E. Gal A. M. Powell
J, G, Thomson James Miller
J. W. Bloome Erasmus Maltby
Jas McGuire Wm Small
[Goochliss Shorr?] James S Crowder
Wm Beach Thomas B Ellis
P. Fitzgerrol E Fitzgerald.
L D Jenks Edwd Boyle
T. W. Morrow S T Wentworth
Wm F Haman Saml D. Martin
George Milsom George W Plunks
Wm Fitzgerald James Smith
Philip A Hill George, Bates
William H. Roche Richard. T. Wait
John Bailey

<Page 3>
Joseph T. Moore John. N. Tuttle
Warren Warner Henry Bowers
William F. Mills
Eneas Scott Puis Chambers
Thos R Wood
Miles Greenwood Edmund. C. Owen
John F Price W. H. C. Temple
M Cornelius Wm M Hubbells
James Powell Ezra. D. Lawrence
Wm M Duval James Hudson
J. A. Ansted Joseph Smith
Jonas Shutt J. Moyer
John. W. Lightfoot Christopher Lee
S B Davies David H Darbyshire
Chs Tea Jos. B Converse
John M. Boyer
Wm Cameron Isaac McDonald
David Tice
J. F. Ballard. Teunis Cox
Hiram Beach Wm Black.
D W Blackman John Clark
T. Chambers A. P. Bodley
Patrick Meener Wm Kelly
John Westlake
Samuel Miller T. Sanborn
E M Mayo Geo. Wilson
S H Harris S Wilson
Joseph Oakes E. Stephens
A. W. Francis G. Bard
Joseph M Duval A J Cox
Samuel Reynolds E T Martin
E S Ayres
N B Gaston Monroe Blake
Josa Woolbuff [Thomas?] Mcilvain
H. M. Varney Evan. R. Evans
Hugh Murnin A Noe
B. F. Jordan
John Hall Saml Devon
Henry Barger. John H Hewes
John G. Hangsche John Weighell
Francis. C. Miller S. W. Castor
George Barnwell T Maddux
Samuel Carpenter Geo, Snowden
John Thompson. J M Hudson
John Pickering H C Wood
J. M. Pickering E. Carney
Robt. M. Marshall Geo. G Hall.
John Ward E Conner.
John Harvard M. Mathias
D P Skerrett D. Punch
C. A. Dusinberry J. Fisher
W H Spence J. Dampman
Wm [Laron?] John. Starr.
W. H Smallwood. Charles H. Grangle
John Reet R. Fisbee
S. Shiner John Duncan.
Wm. H. Archer J. M. [Pfangr?]
E C Cheek. Alexander Kinkaid
John H. Huntland. John Brown
John Mahoney. Middleton Golden.
David Sheeler J. H Kies
George Henning G. Riter
S. S. Agnew. Wm. Smith
Henry Stone John Kircher
Joseph Murdock. Hugh Kennedy
George Higgins. Joel Dillon.
James W. Mitchell. Robt M. Orr.
J. Hall R. Murphy.
M. Frintz John Smith
M. Maliny S Robinson
Ichabod Levering A. Emig
Horace Hithcock John H. Buddeke
Henry M. Ritter Caleb Keighton
Robert Lee Chas. C. Peirce.
D A Aupperle D. Grandbeck
James Canning J H Smith
H B Pearce Edward Chambers
George Runyen M, E, Church
J. H. K. Stephen H. C. Matthews
James. Morrison G H Griswold
Thomas F Duffin Thos R. Blackburn
Jona Blackburn Wm West
H Dane.
G. Crosby J. H Dalton
Joseph Weir Hugh Mcguire
Charles Cavemann Henry F. Russell
August Berk John H Peel
Thomas N Burnett Daniel Banks.
Henry O Connor Benjn F. Huntley
B. Tabor
W. G. Halley James W, W, [Henchor?]
Wm E. Hampton Daniel. T. Judd
Jacob Littel Joseph Bird
Jas. Clark A, Hanna
Phineus Hudson
Robert Miller G, W, Boswell
John Stewart B C. Smith
J L, Hussy Adam V Parker
E S Bedient
George W Thomson A. S Bolling
Wm C Davison William. F Smith.
James Smith F [Battersly?].
Samuel Morris
Christerfur Brown Alexander Stewert
R. S. Thorburm William McDiarmin
Wm Witt George Witt
William Thorp
Gustavus Tassel.

<Page 4>
To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled:
THE PETITION OF THE UNDERSIGNED, INHABITANTS OF CINCINNATI, AND VICINITY,
Respectfully Showeth,
That they have heard, with much regret, of the introduction of a measure for your Legislative sanction, pregnant with serious and lasting evils, and adverse to the spirit of our Republican Institutions, as well as to the deliberate will of the American People.
This measure, which proposes to give, in fee-simple, an immense portion of our National Territory to a single individual, for the purpose of securing the construction of a Railroad from the waters of Lake Michigan to those of the Pacific Ocean, presents, on the most gigantic scale, and in the most injurious and corrupting form, the odious and Aristocratic features of Land Monopoly.
We believe that the immense grant or sacrifice proposed for the promotion of the Railroad scheme of Mr. Whitney, if sanctioned by our National Legislature, will stand as a lasting monument of our folly, and will bring down upon the supporters of this scheme the severest condemnation of the People.
A measure involving consequences so vast and permanent, should not be adopted without distinctly ascertaining that it is in conformity with the will of the American people. No such expression has yet been given by any very large number of the voters of this Republic; and we feel well satisfied, that, should any candidate for the Chief Magistracy of this country avow himself in favor of thus alienating the Public Domain, the odium and opposition thereby excited would ensure his defeat.
Although the power of thus alienating the Public Domain at present rests in Congress, unrestrained by any clause in the Constitution, we believe that so flagrant an abuse of that power would produce a reaction in the public mind, threatening even the repeal of any such grant, and dangerous to the rights which may be acquired under any such system of partial Legislation, tending to revive in this country the system of Landlord Vassalage which has desolated Ireland, and crushed to the earth the laboring population of Europe.
Not only is the proposed measure contrary to the genius of our Democratic Institutions, and corrupting in its tendency, but, as a measure of National Policy, we object earnestly to a scheme which tends to divert emigration from the National Domain to the lands of any individual or Company. And while we are willing that the beneficent energies of our Government should be exerted in the establishment of National Railroads and works of public benefit, we cannot approve of a precedent so anti-Republican, and destructive in its tendency, as the proposed grant.
Believing, therefore, that the will of the People forbids this immense alienation of the National Domain, and that our true policy requires its preservation for the use of the Actual Settler, instead of the Speculator, we, earnestly protest against the proposed measure, and pray that it may be rejected and condemned by your honorable body in the most decisive and emphatic manner.
Nelson Gates Alexr Brown
Edward S. Phillips Samuel McPeake
Henry Keuser. Alfred B Cook
Henry Weismann.
Valduin Ulerick John Finke
George Bingy John Bollner
F. S Hauer Henry Ossege
C Gray Daniel Kieffer
Henry Russe Peter Kerr.
T. Kank
Georg Son H Kramer
Valentin Osburn J Vanfleet
George Adams Henry Padick

<Page 5>
[ docketing ]
Petition of citizens of Cincinnati Ohio, remonstrating against granting the public land prayed for by Asa Whitney and others for the construction of a rail road from Lake Michigan to the Pacific.
[ docketing ]
May 29. 1848 Referred to the Committee of the whole on the State of the Union
[ docketing ]
30th-85
[ docketing ]
Mr Maclay
[ docketing ]
Select Com on Whitney R Road
[ docketing ]
W B Maclay
[NY?]

Printed Document Signed, 5 page(s), Box 232, RG 233: Library of Congress Collection: Records of the U.S. House of Representatives, Library of Congress Collection, 1754-1940