[ docketing
]
No. Subscribers to this Petition 630.
To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America
in Congress assembled:
THE PETITION OF THE UNDERSIGNED, INHABITANTS OF CINCINNATI, AND VICINITY,
Respectfully Showeth,
That they have heard, with much regret, of the introduction of a measure for your Legislative
sanction, pregnant with serious and lasting evils, and adverse to the spirit of our
Republican Institutions, as well as to the deliberate will of the American People.
This measure, which proposes to give, in fee-simple, an immense portion of our National
Territory to a single individual, for the purpose of securing the construction of
a Railroad from the waters of Lake Michigan to those of the Pacific Ocean, presents, on the
most gigantic scale, and in the most injurious and corrupting form, the odious and
Aristocratic features of Land Monopoly.
We believe that the immense grant or sacrifice proposed for the promotion of the Railroad
scheme of Mr. Whitney, if sanctioned by our National Legislature, will stand as a lasting monument of our
folly, and will bring down upon the supporters of this scheme the severest condemnation
of the People.
A measure involving consequences so vast and permanent, should not be adopted without
distinctly ascertaining that it is in conformity with the will of the American people.
No such expression has yet been given by any very large number of the voters of this
Republic; and we feel well satisfied, that, should any candidate for the Chief Magistracy of this country avow himself in favor of thus alienating the Public Domain, the odium
and opposition thereby excited would ensure his defeat.
Although the power of thus alienating the Public Domain at present rests in Congress,
unrestrained by any clause in the Constitution, we believe that so flagrant an abuse
of that power would produce a reaction in the public mind, threatening even the repeal
of any such grant, and dangerous to the rights which may be acquired under any such
system of partial Legislation, tending to revive in this country the system of Landlord Vassalage which has desolated Ireland, and crushed to the earth the laboring population of
Europe.
Not only is the proposed measure contrary to the genius of our Democratic Institutions,
and corrupting in its tendency, but, as a measure of National Policy, we object earnestly
to a scheme which tends to divert emigration from the National Domain to the lands
of any individual or Company. And while we are willing that the beneficent energies
of our Government should be exerted in the establishment of National Railroads and
works of public benefit, we cannot approve of a precedent so anti-Republican, and
destructive in its tendency, as the proposed grant.
Jos. R Buchanan | Samuel Lewis | |
Jos W. Taylor | J. W. Piatt | |
T. V. Morrow | E. Yulie | |
Wm Price | Horace K. Varney | |
L. A Hine | Theodore Nye | |
Chas. Fisher | James Burt | |
P. McGroarty | Alex. W. Roup | |
J. J. Quinn | Wm H Decker | |
G. E. Pugh | A [G?]. Battersley | |
William Morrison | Wm A Brooks | |
Andw M Leslie | Jo Wright | |
T. B. Mary | T. Wright | |
Jas A Murray | S. T. Bender | |
Edward OHare | Wm McIntyre | |
W J Doherty | ||
Wm A. Van Amringe | Stephen Nye | |
W. H. Palmer | Wm Clark | |
Francis Talb | Patrick Boyle | |
James W Stacy | Leonard Neumester | |
Philip Koeniger | ||
Thos E Robinson | Charles L Getty | |
Nelson Gates | Valduin Ulinck | |
Edward S Philips | George Bingey | |
Henry Kenser | F S Hauer | |
Henry Winmann | C. Gray | |
Henry Russe | J Konk | |
Valentine [Anburn?] | Georg Son | |
George Adams | Alexander Brown | |
Samuel McPeake | John Bollner | |
Alfred B Corke | Henry [Onege?] | |
John Finke | Daniel Kieffer | |
Henry Padick | Peter Herr | |
B West | J Van fleet | H Kramer |
[ certification
]
05/15/1848
05/15/1848
Having compared the first Sixty five names upon this petition with the original subscriptions
thereto in pencil and otherwise I hereby certify that this is a faithful transcript
of the original signatures which have been left in my possession.
Jos. R. BuchananCincinnati May 15 1848Robert M Castlan | John Clark |
Israel Price | |
Joseph [?] | Scharl Mott |
T Bergkeger | P. W. Ryan |
B. [N. Gedehoff?] | Andrew Bensing |
Ephraim Sparks | |
Georg Rath | R Hall |
Karl [Neuhaus?] | J F Nordmann |
Jakob Kiessling | Saml D. Towner |
Ludwig Sailz | Ferdinand Roltgen |
Johann [?] | Joseph M Cutler |
[Heinrich Laila?] | Joseph Wibel |
Calvin Walker | |
Peter Fischer | Christ [?] |
Peter W. Reinshagen | J. P. Evans |
Gustav [Hufslerhidt?] | P. Smith |
F Röhrka Sn | Dominik Schwarz |
[?] [Nehery?] | James R Miller |
Heinrich Sachs. | Benjamin Hinebach |
[Walmden?] [Thyl?] | Peter Foy |
Betz: [?] | |
Martin Reichel | Samuel Campbell |
[Joseph?] [Englart?] | John Metz |
J Wilhelm Güntmann | Charles Abbey |
Johann Schoff | Wm C. Phillips |
J. G. Woelfel | Peter. C. Guion |
P. Y. Brown | |
Henry Brüggemann | John Crawford |
Heinrich Walther | H B Katenkamp |
James Ganaver | |
August Hüller. | E [Harvie?] |
Georg Heitz | B. Garmhausen |
H Harsh | A Keller |
J H Gannhausen | C. [Monyrich?] |
George Klanke | W Jaffern |
W Pryme | L. Hart |
J Gray | B Schulte |
H Rose | F Harsch |
M. Parker | |
E Ashley | W. H. Dixon |
P. Ashley | Peter Hummill |
James Hyer | John W. Coleman |
J. N. Towne | T. Salter |
E. Morton | Thos. Jennings |
Sml. Jones | John T. Baker |
Wm Quick | Christopher Lee |
J. E. Towne | Wm Owens |
J. Rabb | Thomas Donaldson |
Benjamin Carroll | J. H Windle |
Joseph [-?] | Thos. H. Walters |
Ira Thomasson | J H Moore |
C. B. Matthews | T. J. Wright |
Thomas Hays | W L McNeil |
James Boid | E R Roe |
M. Parmer | A Potter |
Jacob Stewart | G W Hunt |
Wm Prentiss | J Hance |
R. R. Hopkins | Tho J Orley |
G W Dickey | |
N L Van Sandt | Geo W Wallace |
Thos. L Boucher | Chas. C Schell |
Jesse Garretson | Jos. G. Hunt |
M Wilber | James O Byrne |
A M Stayman | Franklin Talbott |
J Van Amringe | W H McGranagham |
R S Newton | Danl F Morey |
Wm L Marshall | Thos D Cooke |
[ certification
]
05/15/1848Court St. Cincinnati, May 15, 1848.
05/15/1848Court St. Cincinnati, May 15, 1848.
I hereby certify that the 55 names, upon this page are truly copied from the original
subscriptions to the petition against Whitney’s grant
Jos. R Buchanan.<Page 2>
J. P. Whitcomb | J C Walter |
Jacob Waggoner | J W Brown |
Edwin Mattoon | Isaac Cummins |
W. T. Coggshall | J Goslin |
David Stoddart | C W Kastentine |
N. T. Ingersoll | J M Wylie |
T. L. Kirkup | Daniel Finlay |
John Van Amringe | Edward Brennan |
J H Herndon | John Smith |
C C Crandall | Frank Bruce |
P Stille | J. V. Richardson |
Edwin A Lodge | L A Smith |
Obadiah Prentiss | T. Lynch |
J H Stevens | F. Harris |
W. O. Brian | |
T B Gardner | G. N. Frank |
William H Jones | C. I Moore |
Daniel Bukhart | B Ashley |
John Thorpe | G A Smith |
E W Tuttle | H. I. Dodge |
H R Curry | William Moffatt |
W. Wainwright | Henry Clark |
A E Smith | Augustus R. Hynson |
Caleb Carman | R. J. Matthews |
T. M. Brooks | Lawrence Halpin |
[ certification
]
05/15/1848Court Street, Cincinnati, May 15, 1848.
05/15/1848Court Street, Cincinnati, May 15, 1848.
I hereby certify that the fortynine names upon this page are truly copied from the
original subscriptions to the petition against Whitney’s grant which are in my possession.
Jos. R BuchananJames Blinn | E S McClellan |
Cornelius Rowe | |
Thos W Kinsey | Elihue Greene, |
A G Noyes | |
P. J. Moore | S J & A G Noyes |
C. F Conwell | D B Andrews |
P. K. Wombaugh | |
J: J: Browne | Edmd B Blunt |
Daniel McGouran | Charles Howe |
Stephen L. Passel | George L Evans |
E. B. Smith | S. S. Roys |
Evan B Carty | |
Daniel McSwiney | A. Kellogg |
E Blinn Jr | Matthew Simpson |
P. P. L. Prince | D D Lockwood |
O Aldrich | J D Parner |
J Mann | |
J W Rich | J. B. Russell |
S J Orange | Wm C [Oriall?] |
James Cooper | J. F. Taylor. |
John P. Donogh | H H Van Amringe |
R. P. Donogh | Bernard Tynan |
James B. Donogh | A. C. Semple |
J Y Lindsay | |
L. [Repling?] | M Lilley |
John Shaw | John Thompson. |
E A Chandler | A. H. Baldridge |
Geo McGregor | William Glenn |
Ezekiel Cutter | James Whitelock |
Wells H. White | B. F. Fisk |
J H McGeorge | Joseph Draper |
James [Freel?] | Edward Inskip |
J A Milot | Elias Dudley |
Marquis C Winchester | William Ryland |
Edward Stokes | T A. Conway |
Stephen Faulkner. | Charles Vanpelt |
John Darling | |
Ariel Case. 2d | |
J S. Dean | Chas Munroe |
Norman. Collins | |
M B Mann | T. F. Baldwin |
M. Sulzbacher | Jno B. Cobb |
John Elias | |
D J [Willans?] | Charles Woodward |
W H Galbraith | Wm Dod. |
Charles Kelly | W D Griffing |
T. Nasser | Isaac Lyens |
M. T. Brockelbank | Julius [Deitrich?] |
D Dunning. | |
Wm H Oakley. | David Churchill |
Th Townsend | |
M Wallace | Justin M. Thatcher |
R B Cowles | John Cassels Wright |
George. G. Walker | |
R T Goddard | Wm Arons |
H. Truitt | Samuel Boggs |
James Inns | C C Williams |
Rasselar Whitcomb | A P Johnston |
Jacob Graff | C. Moore |
Thomas Martin | L. H. Schell |
R. Cox | James Clark |
D. Uruer | |
John Ewing | G. Fisher |
Joseph Wilson | J. B. Covert |
John H. Coleman64 | J M. Brown |
J. L. Vattier | B. Wise |
A. Pugh | |
George H, Perrine | W. T. Grow |
Geo B Rohrer | |
[F?] | James F. Rhodes |
Harry R Smith | B Archer |
W L Hazen | G. M. Pickering |
Wm Guilford | |
M Ranney | |
F. Clark | |
C. C. Hand | Stephen Maxon |
B Ludowici | A. Smith |
Benj F Gossin | Jeremiah Trotter |
Thomas Pliff | William Teardale |
E Mallinee | |
F Henry Eberle | D. Roth. |
E Hill | Eli Honran |
Jeremiah D [Garrisen?] | Jas, O, Stewart |
C Ratcliff | D W Long |
Levi Parker | |
T Shortill | B Wentworth |
J [Pancoast ?] Jr | W, Saunders |
D F Davis | Alexander Paull |
J. B. Wolcott | Thos Trup |
Wm S Lossin | A Pharis |
Wm E. Gal | A. M. Powell |
J, G, Thomson | James Miller |
J. W. Bloome | Erasmus Maltby |
Jas McGuire | Wm Small |
[Goochliss Shorr?] | James S Crowder |
Wm Beach | Thomas B Ellis |
P. Fitzgerrol | E Fitzgerald. |
L D Jenks | Edwd Boyle |
T. W. Morrow | S T Wentworth |
Wm F Haman | Saml D. Martin |
George Milsom | George W Plunks |
Wm Fitzgerald | James Smith |
Philip A Hill | George, Bates |
William H. Roche | Richard. T. Wait |
John Bailey | |
<Page 3>
|
|
Joseph T. Moore | John. N. Tuttle |
Warren Warner | Henry Bowers |
William F. Mills | |
Eneas Scott | Puis Chambers |
Thos R Wood | |
Miles Greenwood | Edmund. C. Owen |
John F Price | W. H. C. Temple |
M Cornelius | Wm M Hubbells |
James Powell | Ezra. D. Lawrence |
Wm M Duval | James Hudson |
J. A. Ansted | Joseph Smith |
Jonas Shutt | J. Moyer |
John. W. Lightfoot | Christopher Lee |
S B Davies | David H Darbyshire |
Chs Tea | Jos. B Converse |
John M. Boyer | |
Wm Cameron | Isaac McDonald |
David Tice | |
J. F. Ballard. | Teunis Cox |
Hiram Beach | Wm Black. |
D W Blackman | John Clark |
T. Chambers | A. P. Bodley |
Patrick Meener | Wm Kelly |
John Westlake | |
Samuel Miller | T. Sanborn |
E M Mayo | Geo. Wilson |
S H Harris | S Wilson |
Joseph Oakes | E. Stephens |
A. W. Francis | G. Bard |
Joseph M Duval | A J Cox |
Samuel Reynolds | E T Martin |
E S Ayres | |
N B Gaston | Monroe Blake |
Josa Woolbuff | [Thomas?] Mcilvain |
H. M. Varney | Evan. R. Evans |
Hugh Murnin | A Noe |
B. F. Jordan | |
John Hall | Saml Devon |
Henry Barger. | John H Hewes |
John G. Hangsche | John Weighell |
Francis. C. Miller | S. W. Castor |
George Barnwell | T Maddux |
Samuel Carpenter | Geo, Snowden |
John Thompson. | J M Hudson |
John Pickering | H C Wood |
J. M. Pickering | E. Carney |
Robt. M. Marshall | Geo. G Hall. |
John Ward | E Conner. |
John Harvard | M. Mathias |
D P Skerrett | D. Punch |
C. A. Dusinberry | J. Fisher |
W H Spence | J. Dampman |
Wm [Laron?] | John. Starr. |
W. H Smallwood. | Charles H. Grangle |
John Reet | R. Fisbee |
S. Shiner | John Duncan. |
Wm. H. Archer | J. M. [Pfangr?] |
E C Cheek. | Alexander Kinkaid |
John H. Huntland. | John Brown |
John Mahoney. | Middleton Golden. |
David Sheeler | J. H Kies |
George Henning | G. Riter |
S. S. Agnew. | Wm. Smith |
Henry Stone | John Kircher |
Joseph Murdock. | Hugh Kennedy |
George Higgins. | Joel Dillon. |
James W. Mitchell. | Robt M. Orr. |
J. Hall | R. Murphy. |
M. Frintz | John Smith |
M. Maliny | S Robinson |
Ichabod Levering | A. Emig |
Horace Hithcock | John H. Buddeke |
Henry M. Ritter | Caleb Keighton |
Robert Lee | Chas. C. Peirce. |
D A Aupperle | D. Grandbeck |
James Canning | J H Smith |
H B Pearce | Edward Chambers |
George Runyen | M, E, Church |
J. H. K. Stephen | H. C. Matthews |
James. Morrison | G H Griswold |
Thomas F Duffin | Thos R. Blackburn |
Jona Blackburn | Wm West |
H Dane. | |
G. Crosby | J. H Dalton |
Joseph Weir | Hugh Mcguire |
Charles Cavemann | Henry F. Russell |
August Berk | John H Peel |
Thomas N Burnett | Daniel Banks. |
Henry O Connor | Benjn F. Huntley |
B. Tabor | |
W. G. Halley | James W, W, [Henchor?] |
Wm E. Hampton | Daniel. T. Judd |
Jacob Littel | Joseph Bird |
Jas. Clark | A, Hanna |
Phineus Hudson | |
Robert Miller | G, W, Boswell |
John Stewart | B C. Smith |
J L, Hussy | Adam V Parker |
E S Bedient | |
George W Thomson | A. S Bolling |
Wm C Davison | William. F Smith. |
James Smith | F [Battersly?]. |
Samuel Morris | |
Christerfur Brown | Alexander Stewert |
R. S. Thorburm | William McDiarmin |
Wm Witt | George Witt |
William Thorp | |
Gustavus Tassel. |
<Page 4>
To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America
in Congress assembled:THE PETITION OF THE UNDERSIGNED, INHABITANTS OF CINCINNATI, AND VICINITY,
Respectfully Showeth,
That they have heard, with much regret, of the introduction of a measure for your Legislative
sanction, pregnant with serious and lasting evils, and adverse to the spirit of our
Republican Institutions, as well as to the deliberate will of the American People.
This measure, which proposes to give, in fee-simple, an immense portion of our National
Territory to a single individual, for the purpose of securing the construction of
a Railroad from the waters of Lake Michigan to those of the Pacific Ocean, presents, on the
most gigantic scale, and in the most injurious and corrupting form, the odious and
Aristocratic features of Land Monopoly.
We believe that the immense grant or sacrifice proposed for the promotion of the Railroad
scheme of Mr. Whitney, if sanctioned by our National Legislature, will stand as a lasting monument of our
folly, and will bring down upon the supporters of this scheme the severest condemnation
of the People.
A measure involving consequences so vast and permanent, should not be adopted without
distinctly ascertaining that it is in conformity with the will of the American people.
No such expression has yet been given by any very large number of the voters of this
Republic; and we feel well satisfied, that, should any candidate for the Chief Magistracy of this country avow himself in favor of thus alienating the Public Domain, the odium
and opposition thereby excited would ensure his defeat.
Although the power of thus alienating the Public Domain at present rests in Congress,
unrestrained by any clause in the Constitution, we believe that so flagrant an abuse
of that power would produce a reaction in the public mind, threatening even the repeal
of any such grant, and dangerous to the rights which may be acquired under any such
system of partial Legislation, tending to revive in this country the system of Landlord Vassalage which has desolated Ireland, and crushed to the earth the laboring population of
Europe.
Not only is the proposed measure contrary to the genius of our Democratic Institutions,
and corrupting in its tendency, but, as a measure of National Policy, we object earnestly
to a scheme which tends to divert emigration from the National Domain to the lands
of any individual or Company. And while we are willing that the beneficent energies
of our Government should be exerted in the establishment of National Railroads and
works of public benefit, we cannot approve of a precedent so anti-Republican, and
destructive in its tendency, as the proposed grant.
Believing, therefore, that the will of the People forbids this immense alienation
of the National Domain, and that our true policy requires its preservation for the
use of the Actual Settler, instead of the Speculator, we, earnestly protest against the proposed measure, and
pray that it may be rejected and condemned by your honorable body in the most decisive
and emphatic manner.
Nelson Gates | Alexr Brown |
Edward S. Phillips | Samuel McPeake |
Henry Keuser. | Alfred B Cook |
Henry Weismann. | |
Valduin Ulerick | John Finke |
George Bingy | John Bollner |
F. S Hauer | Henry Ossege |
C Gray | Daniel Kieffer |
Henry Russe | Peter Kerr. |
T. Kank | |
Georg Son | H Kramer |
Valentin Osburn | J Vanfleet |
George Adams | Henry Padick |
<Page 5>
[ docketing
]
Petition of citizens of Cincinnati Ohio, remonstrating against granting the public
land prayed for by Asa Whitney and others for the construction of a rail road from
Lake Michigan to the Pacific.
[ docketing
]
May 29. 1848 Referred to the Committee of the whole on the State of the Union
[ docketing
]
30th-85
[ docketing
]
Mr Maclay
[ docketing
]
Select Com on Whitney R Road
[ docketing
]
W B Maclay
[NY?]
[NY?]
Printed Document Signed, 5 page(s), Box 232, RG 233: Library of Congress Collection: Records of the U.S. House of Representatives, Library of Congress Collection, 1754-1940