John J. Crittenden to Abraham Lincoln, 27 October 18581
Frankfort– Octr: 27th 1858.My Dear Sir,I have just been apprised that a paragraph in the St: Louis Republican (I think, that is the paper) contains some allusion to our private correspondence, and assumes to call on your for it's publication.2
This has given me much pain & surprise. I do not believe that you would ever have
entertained a suspicion that I was capable of betraying that correspondence, & of
causing or prompting, in any way, the paragraph above mentioned– But yet I desire
to assure you that I have had no art or part, agency or privity in respect to it,
or its publication– It is wholly unauthorised by me. I should have considered myself dishonored, if I could ever have consented
to, or permitted any use to be made of our correspondence, that would have been injurious
or embarrassing to you–3
I hope that this will
I am,<Page 2>
be satisfactory to you— and, furthermore, I hope that you will not permit this publication
to annoy you, half as much as it annoys me.
Very Truly & Respectfully
yr's[yours] &c[etc.]J J CrittendenHon. A. Lincoln
<Page 3>
<Page 4>
2The paragraph Crittenden alludes to appeared in the October 25, 1858, issue of the
Daily Missouri Republican.
Abraham Lincoln was the Republican candidate from Illinois for the U.S. Senate in 1858, running against Democrat Stephen A. Douglas, the incumbent. At this time the Illinois General Assembly elected the state’s representatives in the U.S. Senate, thus the outcome of races
for the Illinois House of Representatives and Illinois Senate in the election of 1858 were of importance in the campaign. Lincoln and Douglas both
focused their campaign efforts on the former Whig stronghold of central Illinois, where the state legislative races were the closest.
See the 1858 Illinois Republican Convention; 1858 Federal Election. On July 7, Lincoln wrote to his former congressional colleague John J. Crittenden of Kentucky to ask whether rumors of Crittenden’s support for Douglas were true. An eminent
former Whig, Crittenden was widely regarded as the natural successor to Henry Clay, and Lincoln worried that a Crittenden endorsement for Douglas would hurt his chances
with his former Whig brethren in Illinois. Crittenden welcomed Lincoln's rise to political
prominence, but had little sympathy with the Republican Party. Crittenden responded on July 29, assuring Lincoln that he was remembered favorably. Crittenden explained,
however, that he and Douglas, though always belonging to different political parties
and "opposed, in politics, to each other," shared a strong aversion to the Lecompton Constitution. The Buchanan administration's harsh response to Douglas and use of its power to prevent his reelection
brought sympathy from Crittenden. He wrote of Douglas, "I could not but wish for his
success— and his triumph over such a persecution– I thought that his reelection was
necessary as a rebuke to the Administration, and a vindication of the great cause
of popular rights & public justice." Crittenden admitted that he had shared his support
of Douglas in various conversations but that he had only sent a handful of letters
in which "Mr Douglas was alluded to and recommended." Going forward, he wrote, he
could not promise anything, only that, "Whatever my future course may be, I trust
that I shall so act as to give no just cause of offence to any candid & liberal friend,
even tho' he may differ with me in opinion."
Though expressing "no disposition for officious intermeddling" in his letter to Lincoln,
Crittenden nonetheless became embroiled in the campaign for the U.S. Senate. On July
19, T. Lyle Dickey, a former Whig and Lincoln supporter who had defected to the Democrats and Douglas,
wrote Crittenden requesting that he confirm a conversation with Dickey in April 1858
where Crittenden praised Douglas. On August 1, Crittenden wrote Dickey confirming
the conversation and his praise for Douglas's service to Illinois and his principled
position on the Lecompton Constitution. Not wishing to be appear "to be an officious
intermeddler" in the election, Crittenden requested that Dickey, should he speak of
the conversation or letter, "acquit me of any intermeddling, or of the presumption
of seeking to obtrude myself or my sentiments upon the attention of the people of
Illinois." Dickey kept the letter private until October 19, when he read it aloud
in a speech denouncing Lincoln for abandoning Clay and Whiggery. The Daily Illinois State Journal sought to mitigate the damage by claiming that Crittenden's letter to Dickey was
a forgery and by suggesting that Crittenden had written Lincoln--presumably Crittenden's
letter of July 29--supporting opposition against Douglas. The Daily Missouri Republican demanded that Lincoln publish this letter. The Illinois State Journal continued to misrepresent Crittenden's correspondence to Lincoln, prompting Owen
G. Cates of Saint Louis to write Crittenden asking if he wrote such a letter. On October 28, Crittenden responded
in a telegram: "I have written no such letter." Crittenden's letter to Dickey, Dickey's
speech, and Crittenden's subsequent telegram hurt Lincoln in the old Whig stronghold
of Central Illinois, contributing to Democrats retaining control of the General Assembly,
allowing Douglas to win reelection.
Michael Burlingame, Abraham Lincoln: A Life(Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008), 1:456-57, 476-77, 542-43, 546-47;
Allen C. Guelzo, “Houses Divided: Lincoln, Douglas, and the Political Landscape of
1858,” The Journal of American History 94 (September 2007), 394, 400-401; Allen C. Guelzo, Lincoln and Douglas: The Debates that Defined America (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008) , 273-76; The Louisville Daily Journal (Louisville, KY), 26 October 1858, 2:1; Daily Missouri Republican (Saint Louis, MO), 25 October 1858, 2:1; 29 October 1858, 2:1.
3David Davis, Henry C. Whitney, and others blamed Crittenden for Lincoln's defeat, and Lincoln himself, in his reply to this letter, claimed that the use of Crittenden's name in the U.S. Senate campaign
"contributed largely" to his loss. Still, Lincoln assured Crittenden that even while
feeling defeated, he did not suspect Crittenden of “anything dishonorable.”
David Davis to Abraham Lincoln; Henry C. Whitney to Abraham Lincoln.
Autograph Letter Signed, 4 page(s), Abraham Lincoln Papers, Library of Congress (Washington, DC).