1Executive Department,
Vandalia, July 11, 1837.To the Senate and House of Representatives:Gentlemen:—
Vandalia, July 11, 1837.To the Senate and House of Representatives:Gentlemen:—
In my message at the opening of the last session it was my happiness to congratulate you on the
pros-
<Page 2>
perity then so eminently enjoyed by every portion of our beloved country; and from
my inmost heart did I rejoice to see the industrious citizen every where reap the
rich rewards of his labor. And although even then, I was not without strong apprehensions
of an early reverse, I am confident no human forecast could have anticipated, so sudden
a calamity as has been brought upon the country by the action of the Federal Government
upon its currency. At the time the President of the United States assumed the responsibility of ordering the public moneys to
be removed from their legal deposite in the Bank of the United States, for the purpose, as he avowed, of preventing the re-charter of that institution by Congress, there never was a sounder currency, or a more healthy state of things in any government
in the world. To effect this great object, namely, that of destroying the United States Bank, rival institutions were to be created: and it will be remembered that immediately
after the removal of the deposits the Government party commenced establishing State
Banks, whilst State Legislatures, deluded by the fallacious promise of advantages
to be derived from the deposites to be made in these institutions, which were to be
fiscal agents of Government, readily fell into the measure. As might have been expected,
hundreds of new banks instantly sprung up, their enormous issues of irredeemable paper
afforded the inducement of universal extravagant speculation, and gave us what all
must now regard a depraved and worthless currency.
Before the public were aware of the ruin which this wild scheme portended, the Executive and a portion of its party seeing their error it would seem, endeavored to escape
its consequences by amusing the people with the absurd and impracticable project of
an exclusive hard money currency. I say absurd—for as well might the Executive of the United States expect to compel the citizens of the great valley to abandon
the use of steam boats and resume the flat bottom and barge in the navigation of its
thousand streams and rivers as to force them to give up a sound paper currency, at
all times convertible into specie, with all its adaptedness to the purposes of the
commerce and business of the country. Before such a scheme can be prosecuted to the
results they promised, the intelligence, commerce, liberties and boundaries of all
of these United States must be obliterated, and the people yield to the stubborn will
and rule of a despot. These Experiments, as they have been styled by their authors, may and I believe have had
<Page 3>
their political effect; but they have also had their effect upon the country acknowledged to be full
of resources, distinguished for its intelligence, its enterprise, and wonderful prosperity,
in reducing it to an almost universal bankruptcy; in prostrating alike its business,
its energies, and confidence.
It was in view of the motive which dictated the measure, and in anticipation of some
of these results, that I opposed at first, the establishment of the State Bank of Illinois; as I did also last winter, both the increase of its capital and that of the Bank of Shawneetown.
But it is easier sometimes, to trace the causes of evils, than to find out a remedy
for them. The enquiry, however, is important and useful, as the discovery of the
cause, not unfrequently suggests the remedy. That you will have it in your power,
to do all demanded by the present exigency, is more than I dare hope. Probably as
much as can at present be effected, will be to place our own State in such an attitude, as to parry off the blow, and stay as far as possible, the effects
of the crisis upon our interests, until Congress, the only legitimate power under our Constitution, shall regulate the currency, and
restore it to its former sound condition and beneficent action.
The connection of the State with the Banks of Illinois, renders an attention to its affairs, a matter of immediate
and imperative duty.
By an act to increase the capital stock of certain Banks, &c.[etc.] approved March 4th, 1837, it is made the duty of the Fund Commissioners, to subscribe
two millions of dollars to the State Bank of Illinois, and one million to the stock of the Bank of Illinois at Shawneetown; and by the 11th section of said act, the Bank is made the fiscal agent of the State. One thousand shares of the stock of the State Bank of Illinois were subscribed for by the State, for which $100,000 of public money was paid in MARCH last. The Bank took the loan negotiated last year in New York, of $100,000, for which it agrees to place a credit in the Bank, to the Canal Fund for $105,000, including five per cent. premium. It has also agreed
to pay the State Bonds for the Wiggins’ loan of $100,000. The Auditor’s books show a deposite of State funds now in the Bank of $388,669[.]51. The report of the Canal Commissioner, of the 23d of May, shews a deposite of Canal funds in the Branch at Chicago, to the amount of $285,834[.]89.
There is $60,000 of the State funds on deposite in the
<Page 4>
Bank at Shawneetown, and the Commissioners of the School Fund, hold a draft from the Treasury of the
United States on it for $16,100, which several sums make the responsibilities of these
Banks to the State, amount to $1,055,604[.]40. These Banks both having stopped paying their notes in specie in May last, and
as by the 25th section of the act, incorporating the State Bank of Illinois,—approved Feb. 12th, 1835, and by the supplement to said act, Approved January 18th,
1836, it is provided, that if said corporation shall neglect or refuse to pay its notes in specie for sixty days, it forfeits its
charter, and is required immediately to discontinue all its operations, except for
receiving and collecting its debts; and as it is believed, that while all other Banks
refuse, the Banks of no one State, however solvent, can safely or long continue to
pay specie for their notes; it will be perceived, at once, that immediate Legislative action
is indispensable for the protection and security of those important interests. In
the adoption of any measure which your wisdom may suggest, in relation to the Banks,
or for the better security of the interests of the State connected with them, care should be taken to require a reduction of their notes in
circulation, and prevent any increase of their responsibilities, so as to ensure a
resumption of specie payments as early as possible.
It can admit of no doubt, that if the Banks of Illinois, which are known to be as solvent as any other banks in the country, under existing
circumstances, were to persist in paying out specie for their notes, the result would
be, at no long period, an entire transfer from their own to the vaults of other Banks—the
ultimate but sure loss of their capital—the imminent jeopardy of the State funds—and be so crippled, if not crushed in their operations, as to embarrass most
seriously, the movements of the community at large; and not less seriously, the improvements,
business, and commerce of the State, with all of which it is intimately connected.
For the same important considerations that I opposed the act, requiring the Fund Commissioners
to subscribe on behalf of the State for three millions of dollars of the stock of those Banks, to be paid for by the
sale of State bonds, I am now satisfied ought to be repealed forthwith, and do accordingly recommend
it to be done.
Your attention should also be directed to the Surplus Revenue, the fourth instalment of which becomes due on the 30th day of September next; inasmuch as the Banks in
which it
<Page 5>
was deposited have all stopped specie payments; and your resolution requires the Treasurer
to receive it only in specie, which at present is impracticable.
In the midst of the disasters which have already fallen on the commercial world, and
which are still threatening us on all sides, a favorable opportunity occurs to escape
from the perils of that system of Internal Improvements adopted last winter, which
to my apprehension os so fr[a]ught with evil: and for the reason assigned when I refused my assent to the enactment
passed in its favor, as well as from existing pecuniary troubles and derangements,
I now recommend its repeal.—Aware that it is always difficult, and sometimes grievous,
at least partially, to abandon even a bad system after the interests of society have
become identified with it, it is with reluctance, much more in regard to this fact,
than hesitation as to the propriety of the step, that I urge the recommendation: especially,
too, as my conviction is deep and firm that such undertakings belong rather to arbitrary
and despotic Governments, than to the republican institutions of a free people, as
by the power of patronage and official influence, they tend to corrupt the many and
exalt the few. In all the melancholy histories of departed liberty, the process of
decay commenced in the people’s neglect and disuse of their own rights and privileges,
and progressed in the ignorant and fatuous transfer of them to their rulers. And of
all the dark symptoms which indicate the evil at work in our own system, none seems
so fearful, so alarming, as the steady, nay, rapid departure of power from the hands
of the people to the hands of the Government—a fact sufficiently obvious to all who
have observed the political movements of the last eight years.
If to the power and influence which necessarily belong to political station there
be added the immense patronage no less involved in extended public works, there may
come a struggle between the people and their rulers; but too late for the former to
regain what the latter have stolen. Let the present pernicious system be rescinded,
and in its stead adopt the safer, the more generous, more economical, most expeditious,
and in every respect the preferable plan of encouraging private individuals and corporations
by suitable aid from the State—and thus escape the intrigue, venality, waste and corruption inherent in that patronage
which must grow out of such as system as the present.
A report of the Board of Internal Improvements to the Executive of 5th June, is herewith
enclosed, which exhibits its operations to date. A report and correspondence of the
Canal Commissioners are also transmitted. By the correspondence, it will be seen that
the calling of the Legislature together has been urged upon the Executive by them as necessary for the carrying
on of that favorite work, and because of the probable difficulty of collecting the
2d instalment on the lots sold in Chicago, which fell due on the 20th of June last.
<Page 6>
Having received a letter from the Board informing me they would make a full report
to the Legislature of all their operations present and plans for the future, I will leave this subject
with an earnest recommendation of it to your fostering care: hoping that this great
work will be carried forward with all the expedition, consistent with a just economy.
As I consider it a national work, and ourselves as managers of the fund, appropriated
by Congress for its accomplishment, it would seem to be our duty faithfully to apply these means;
and upon its completion, after a suitable reservation for repairs and improvements,
and with due consideration for the rights of the State, it will be equally our duty and interest to make this canal free as the waters of the lake.
Unpleasant as the subject is to myself, and may be to others, I feel bound again to
call your attention, and through you that of our constituents, to the affairs of our
National Government, especially of its Executive branch; to the action of which I
confidently believe many of the evils we are now suffering, and with which we are
threatened, are fairly to be attributed. There must be change there must be reform.
The Public Treasury must be again firmly placed in the custody of the law; and all
power and control over it by the Executive of the United States must be repudiated.
The Executive should be prohibited under severe penalties from establishing a rule
in violation of law to collect the revenue in one quarter of the country in specie
only, and in another to collect in bank paper; or from using any other means for diverting
the specie (which is the only safe basis of exchanges) from the ordinary channels
of business. Congress must regulate the currency by law, and place it out of Executive or official power,
either to try experiments, or make speculations upon it. The patronage of the Executive
must be reduced, and his power to remove public officers so modified as to prevent
his displacing a faithful and competent man, either to gratify party malice, or to
intimidate him in the free and independent exercise of the elective franchise; so,
also, as will secure him against Executive tyranny, and all control over his official
acts, except such as the law imposes; that his qualifications, fidelity and ability,
may be his only hope of retaining office.
That control over the public press and Congress which has been so powerfully exercised by the appointment of newspaper editors and
members of the Senate and House of Representatives to high and lucrative offices by the Executive, should as far as possible be obviated.
The constitutional and legal right of each or both Houses of Congress to examine into the official conduct of every officer in the Government, should be
clearly established, as it is the only efficient check the people have upon their
public servants; whilst public expenditures must be reduced and more economy and simplicity
in the administration of Government be observed, before we can ever be secure of these
ines-
With great respect, your obd’t[obedient] servant,JOSEPH DUNCAN.<Page 7>
timable blessings hitherto enjoyed under our constitution and excellent form of Government.
I pray gentlemen, that the State may experience the full measure of your patriotism. Never was wisdom from above to
direct your counsels, more to be implored than at this moment. Party spirit in its
mildest form has ever been found an enemy to liberty and sound legislation: but when
it is the offspring of ambition and avarice, directed by designing bad men in high
places, it begets a blind devotion and infuriated zeal, which shuts the door against
all reason, justice and patriotism. May God in his infinite wisdom and mercy avert
such an evil from this country, and that justice and the laws may prevail, and that
every man in this broad land may sit down again with confidence under the shadow
of the constitution in the peaceable and quiet enjoyment of his rights and privileges.
No power must be allowed to exist in this country superior to that of the people,
or that does not acknowledge the supreme and inflexible authority of the law as the
rule of action both for the President and every other functionary of the Government.
1On July 11, 1837, Alexander P. Field presented to the House of Representatives the following communication from Governor Joseph Duncan. The House referred the portions of it that related to the State Bank of Illinois and the Bank of Illinois at Shawneetown to the Committee on Finance, of which Abraham Lincoln was a member. On July 12, the House referred the portions relating to the surplus revenue to the Committee of the Whole.
Journal of the House of Representatives of the Tenth General Assembly of the State
of Illinois, at a Special Session, (Vandalia, IL: William Walters, 1837), .
Printed Transcription, 7 page(s), Journal of the House of Representatives of the Tenth General Assembly of the State of Illinois, at a Special Session (Vandalia, IL: William Walters, 1837), 9-15