Lyman Trumbull to Abraham Lincoln, 7 December 18581
Washington, Dec. 7– 1858.My Dear Sir,I have just recd[received] the enclosed letter from John C. Underwood of New York City. Mr. U. is the Gentleman who was driven out of Virginia two years ago, because he attended the Fremont convention–2 I was not aware that you had any idea of being a candidate for congress in the 6th Dist.[District] & in all candour, must say I should be sorry to have you a candidate unless there was a fair chance
for success–3 It would certainly be a great triumph & have a most happy effect in the future if
you could be returned from the district
<Page 2>
right on the eve of a four thousand majority against us.4 My object in writing is to apprise you of the suggestions of Mr. Underwood, & particularly
the one at the close of the letter which might be important if a serious fight is
to be made in the District–
I trust our people will run some one & give him the best vote possible, & I am not
sure that at a special election, we might ^not^ succeed if the proper efforts were made– I have no doubt the same vote given Matheny would elect at the special election–
The proceedings in the Va. convention are a severe rebuke upon Douglas– The feeling of the Administration against Douglas is as bitter as ever, but what
to do, I think they do not themselves know– The message
Yours trulyLyman Trumbull6<Page 3>
draws the line against Douglas pretty distinctly–5<Page 4>
[ enclosure
]
12/06/1858
12/06/1858
Underwood, John C.New York, New YorkTrumbull, Lyman
John C. Underwood to Lyman Trumbull
OFFICE OF THE
American Emigrant Aid and Homestead Company,
19 NASSAU STREET, (Room No. 1, Second Floor.)
New York,December 6th1858Hon Lyman TrumbullDear SirAmerican Emigrant Aid and Homestead Company,
19 NASSAU STREET, (Room No. 1, Second Floor.)
I deem the election of Mr Lincoln in the Springfield District on the 4th Ult so important,7 that I want to do something to aid it– Would not the immediate circulation of Col Bentons last great work Review of the Dred Scott decision of the Sup Court be a good thing8 If so I think the Republicans of this city would enter into it with Spirit
You will excuse me for troubling you, but I have seen such great results from a little
work in Western Va[Virginia], the last two years that I wish to do more– As one of the outgrowths of our Homestead Company's operations, we have seen a daily & triweekly paper (The Wheeling Intelligencer) & the following weeklies, The Ceredo Crescent, The Weekly Intelligencer, The Wellsburg Herald & Brooke Co Farmer, advocating Republican principles in Western Va– If there is any thing for me to do in securing the Springfield District I would
like to Record it & to work in securing books or funds with the greatest pleasure
Yours TrulyJohn. C. Underwood9<Page 5>
<Page 6>
<Page 7>
[ endorsement
]
F. 1800
B. 1400
F. 1100
B. 1400
F. 1100
<Page 8>
[Envelope]
L. Trumbull
U.S. SWASHINGTON CITY [DC?] FREE
DEC[DECEMBER] 8 1858Hon. A. Lincoln,Springfield,Illinois.
U.S. SWASHINGTON CITY [DC?] FREE
DEC[DECEMBER] 8 1858Hon. A. Lincoln,Springfield,Illinois.
1Lyman Trumbull wrote and signed this letter including the frank and Abraham Lincoln’s
address on the envelope. See image eight.
2 The “Fremont Convention” was 1856 Republican National Convention. Delegates to the convention nominated John C. Fremont for president. John C. Underwood traveled from his home in Virginia to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to attend the convention. After the nomination of William L. Dayton for vice-president, Underwood delivered a speech in support of the party’s candidates
that included fiery anti-slavery rhetoric. Underwood’s participation in the convention
and anti-slavery rhetoric drew the ire of his slaveholding Virginia neighbors.
Warned by his wife to remain in the North, Underwood sent for his wife and child and
took them to New York City. During the presidential campaign, Underwood delivered numerous speeches supporting Fremont and bemoaning the negative
impact of slavery on Virginia. Underwood received threats after returning to his
home in Virginia and realized his and his family’s lives were in danger if violence
were to break out. This led him to sell his belongings and move from Virginia to New
York City, a story he would write about and publish in the New York Times.
Richard G. Miles, “The Republican Party in Antebellum Virginia, 1856-1860,” The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 81 (July 1973), 261-64, 266; New-York Daily Times NY), 6 January 1857 3:3-4.
3Trumbull references the upcoming special election held for U.S. representative in
the Illinois Sixth Congressional District. Thomas L. Harris, a Democrat from Petersburg, Illinois, who represented the Sixth Illinois Congressional District in the U.S. House of Representatives, won reelection in November 1858, defeating James H. Matheny, his Republican opponent, with 57.6 percent of the vote. Harris died on November 24, 1858, before
he was able to be sworn in for the second session of the Thirty-Fifth Congress. Article one, section two, clause four of the U.S. Constitution mandated that chief
executives of the states issue writs of election for special elections to fill vacancies
in the U.S. House of Representatives. Governor William H. Bissell issued a writ of election on November 29, 1858 for a special election to be held
on January 4, 1859 to fill Harris’s vacated seat for the second session of the Thirty-Fifth
Congress. Albert S. Brooks, William S. Frink, and Richard Yates also corresponded with Lincoln about the special election.
Howard W. Allen and Vincent A. Lacey, eds., Illinois Elections, 1818-1990 (Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press, 1992), 10, 11;
Daily Illinois State Register (Springfield), 25 November 1858, 2:1; Daily Illinois State Journal (Springfield, IL), 1 December 1858, 2:4; Biographical Directory of the American Congress 1774-1996 (Alexandria, VA: CQ Staff Directories, 1997), 155, 1168; U.S. Const. art. I, § 2,
cl. 4; Kenneth C. Martis, The Historical Atlas of Political Parties in the United States Congress, 1789-1989 (New York: MacMillan, 1989), 110-11; The Lincoln Log: A Daily Chronology of the Life of Abraham Lincoln, 4 January 1859, https://thelincolnlog.org/Results.aspx?type=CalendarDay&day=1859-01-04&r; Albert S. Brooks to Abraham Lincoln; William S. Frink to Abraham Lincoln; Richard Yates to Abraham Lincoln.
4Harris defeated Matheny in the election for U.S. Congress held on November 2, 1858,
by 16,193 votes to 11,646 votes, a difference of 4,547 votes.
The Weekly Chicago Times (IL), 11 November 1858, 2:5-7; Kenneth C. Martis, The Historical Atlas of Political Parties in the United States Congress, 1789-1989, 110-11; Howard W. Allen and Vincent A. Lacey, eds., Illinois Elections, 1818-1990, 11, 143.
5 The Virginia State Democratic Convention was held in Petersburg, Virginia, and started on December 2, 1858. Delegates gather to select it the Democratic gubernatorial
candidate for the general election in 1859. The meeting became raucous and disorderly,
as delegates differed over the candidacy of John Letcher, the presumptive frontrunner, who had once endorsed gradual emancipation but had
long since ranted his earlier view as political heresy. Letcher would receive the
nomination, and the conventioneers approved two resolutions, one endorsing President
James Buchanan and his administration, and the other congratulating Stephen A. Douglas for winning reelection to the U.S. Senate.
Douglas broke with President Buchanan and his administration in December 1857 over
the Lecompton Constitution, causing a rift in the Democratic Party. Douglas’s split from President Buchanan
and his adherents threatened Douglas’s bid for reelection to the U.S. Senate, which
Illinois Republicans hoped to capitalize on by nominating Lincoln to challenge Douglas
for the seat. Republican won the majority of all the votes cast in the local elections
of November 2, 1858, but pro-Douglas Democrats retained control of the Illinois General Assembly, which elected U.S. senators in those days, allowing Douglas to win reelection to
the U.S. Senate. Douglas's victory was confirmed in the election held on January
5, 1859. Although winning reelection, Douglas faced open hostility from his Democratic
colleagues when he returned to Washington, DC, for the second session of the Thirty-Fifth Congress, which opened on December 6, 1858.
Daily Illinois State Journal (Springfield), 3 November 1858, 2:1; Michael Burlingame, Abraham Lincoln: A Life (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008), 1:445-50, 458-60, 492-540,
556-57; Allen C. Guelzo, “Houses Divided: Lincoln, Douglas, and the Political Landscape
of 1858,” The Journal of American History 94 (September 2007), 392-94, 414-16; Illinois Senate Journal. 1859. 21st G. A., 30; Illinois House Journal. 1859. 21st G. A., 32; Robert W. Johannsen, Stephen A. Douglas (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1997), 668, 670, 685-90; The Daily Dispatch (Richmond, VA), 3 December 1858, 2:2, 3-4; 4 December 1858, 1:3-4; 6 December 1858,
1:3-6; F. N. Boney, “Letcher, John,” American National Biography
, ed. by John A. Garraty and Mark C. Carnes (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999),
13:526; W. G. Bean, “John Letcher and the Slavery Issue in Virginia’s Gubernatorial
Contest of 1858-1859,” The Journal of Southern History 20 (February 1954), 33-35.
6In his response to this letter dated December 11, 1858, Lincoln wrote that had not “the slightest
thought” of becoming a candidate to fill the vacancy brought on by Harris’s death.
Contemplating the options facing Republicans for the special election, Lincoln noted
that some Republicans favored running their own candidate, while others favored staying
out and allowing the Democrats to run multiple candidates and split the vote. The
Republicans ultimately decided on the former course, running James C. Conkling against the Democratic candidate, Charles D. Hodges. Hodges polled 11,014 votes to 6,951 for Conkling, a difference of 4,063 votes.
Hodges won the election with 61 percent of the vote and took his seat on January 20,
1859.
Howard W. Allen and Vincent A. Lacey, eds., Illinois Elections, 1818-1990, 11, 143; Biographical Directory of the American Congress 1774-1996, 155; Daily Illinois State Journal (Springfield) 15 January 1859, 2:1; The Weekly Pantagraph (Bloomington, IL), 26 January 1859, 1:4; Kenneth C. Martis, The Historical Atlas of Political Parties in the United States Congress, 1789-1989, 110-11; The Lincoln Log: A Daily Chronology of the Life of Abraham Lincoln, 4 January 1859, https://thelincolnlog.org/Results.aspx?type=CalendarDay&day=1859-01-04&r; U.S. House Journal. 1859. 35th Cong., 2nd sess., 225.
8Thomas Hart Benton published a book in 1857 critiquing the Dred Scott Decision
and detailing his opposition to it.
Thomas Hart Benton, Historical and Legal Examination of that Part of the Decision of the Supreme Court
of the United States in the Dred Scott Case (New York: D. Appleton, 1857); Elbert B. Smith, "Benton, Thomas Hart," American National Biography, ed. by John A. Garraty and Mark C. Carnes (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999),
2:618-20.
Autograph Letter Signed, 8 page(s), Abraham Lincoln Papers, Library of Congress (Washington, DC).