Richard Thorne to Abraham Lincoln, 5 February 18591
Ottawa Feby 5th 1859Hon A. LincolnDear SirFrom information that I received yesterday, I have come to the conclusion that Govr Bissell will make a new appointment for Canal Trustee in place of Dr Ray.2 I know of but one person here who will be an applicant ^besides myself^ and that is Mr Glover. he was an applicant two years ago, is the only reason that I suppose he may be
one now. Except that Mr Cook being in the Senate, of course will do all he can for his firm—the Republicans of this County have dealt very liberly[liberally] with the firm of Cook & Glover— and for the Good of the party here, they ought not to insist on the appointment of Mr Glover to this office.3 The Whig Wing of the republican party ought to have this appointment, it is due to them, and I think if you should be satisfied
the Govr has determined to make a new appointment, then to consult with Mr Cook, and urge
him to Let me have the appointment as an Old Whig, and
<Page 2>
for the union and benefit of the party here, and particularly for Mr Cooks political interest that you could bring about my appointment, at all events I am willing to submit it
to you to do as you think proper, if you will take any interest in the case for me.
The Republicans here can be united on me for this office if necessary in order to
have any effect on the Govr[Governor] I hope you will have the Kindness to write me on the Receipt of this, and advise
me what you think is for my interest4
Yours trulyR. Thorne5<Page 3>
[Envelope]
OTTAWA Ill.[Illinois]
FEB[FEBRUARY] 5 1859Hon A LincolnSpringfieldIll
FEB[FEBRUARY] 5 1859Hon A LincolnSpringfieldIll
1Richard Thorne wrote and signed this letter including Abraham Lincoln’s name and address
on the envelope.
2Charles H. Ray was one of three commissioners on the Board of Trustees of the Illinois and Michigan Canal. David Leavitt and William H. Swift were the two other commissioners. Under the legislation creating the Board of Trustees,
subscribers of the loan to build the canal appointed or elected two trustees and the
governor of Illinois appointed one trustee. Governor William H. Bissell appointed
Ray as a trustee in January 1857.
The “information” Thorne references might have been the results of an investigation
by the Illinois General Assembly regarding a $40,000 payment to Leavitt. In 1843 the Illinois General Assembly passed an act authorizing the governor of Illinois to negotiate a loan of $1,600,000
to fund work on the Illinois and Michigan Canal. After a year of securing loans, the canal was still about $200,000 underfunded.
The commissioners sent Leavitt to secure the remaining required loans. This was in
part due to the fact that Leavitt was also a major debt holder for the canal project,
holding $250,000 in canal bonds, as well as being the owner of an additional $100,000
loan given to the canal fund. The other commissioners assumed that his personal stake
in the project would help him convince foreign stakeholders to increase their loans.
As such, he went to Europe in 1844 and was able to secure the $200,000. Beginning in 1845, Leavitt repeatedly
submitted a claim to the Illinois and Michigan Canal to be paid a commission of $40,000
as compensation for helping to secure the money for the loan.
In his capacity as a member of the Board of Trustees, Ray had introduced a resolution
in October 1857 authorizing payment of this sum, which Leavitt, also a trustee, had
signed. Leavitt and Ray argued that their signatures on the resolution constituted
the approval of a majority of the three-person Board of Trustees, and Leavitt, the
board treasurer, charged the $40,000 to his treasurer’s report for 1857. Swift protested,
and the canal’s bondholders in England directed their agent in the United States to file suit in the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to recover the money from Leavitt.
The General Assembly launched an investigation into this payment and released their
report to the public on February 5, 1859. Leavitt was found to act on his own accord
rather than under direction of State government and both Ray and Leavitt were found
to be in the wrong. Leavitt was ultimately allowed $10,000 of the sum he had claimed,
and was ordered in 1863 to repay $32,063.90 plus court costs. Bondholders of the
Illinois and Michigan Canal voted to replace Leavitt as trustee with Henry Grinnell in June 1859. Ray wrote Lincoln three letters requesting his legal opinion on Leavitt’s
claim.
Illinois House Journal. 1863. 23rd G. A., 655-58; “An Act to Provide for the Completion of the Illinois
and Michigan Canal, and for the Payment of the Canal Debt,” 21 February 1843, Laws of Illinois (1843), 54-61; “An Act Supplemental to ‘An Act to Provide for the Completion of
the Illinois and Michigan Canal, and for the Payment of the Canal Debt,’ Approved,
February 21st, One Thousand Eight Hundred and Forty-Three,” 1 March 1845, Revised Statutes of Illinois (1845), 600-601; The Weekly Chicago Times (IL), 10 February 1859, 2:1, 4-5; Chicago Daily Press and Tribune (IL), 10 February 1859, 1:1; Daily Illinois State Register (Springfield, IL), 10 February 1859, 2:3; 4 June 1859, 2:2; Illinois House Journal. 1859. 21st G. A., 504-5; Charles H. Ray to Abraham Lincoln; Charles H. Ray to Abraham Lincoln; Charles H. Ray to Abraham Lincoln; Ray asked Lincoln for legal advice, Martha L. Benner and Cullom Davis et al., eds., The Law Practice of Abraham Lincoln: Complete Documentary Edition, 2d edition (Springfield: Illinois Historic Preservation Agency, 2009), https://www.lawpracticeofabrahamlincoln.org/Details.aspx?case=141837.
3Joseph O. Glover partnered with Burton C. Cook and the two started practicing law
together in 1840. Both were Democrats that would later switch parties to the Republican Party after its founding. As he
writes, Thorne was formerly a Whig, as was Lincoln.
The Republican Party was formed in the aftermath of the fall of the Whig Party, which
split into regional factions after the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act. Northern Whigs abandoned the party and formed the core of the newly formed Republican
Party while many Southern Whigs became members of the Know-Nothing Party. The Democrat Party was suffering its own fractures at the same time, with many Northern
Democrats leaving the party over its focus on pro-slavery politics and joining the
new Republican Party. People would often feel more agreeable to Republicans that shared
a similar background as opposed to those who used to be political enemies.
Elmer Baldwin, History of La Salle County Illinois
(Chicago: Rand, McNally, 1877), 245; The Daily Inter Ocean
(Chicago, IL), 11 December 1891, 2:4; Newton Bateman and Paul Selby, eds., Historical Encyclopedia of Illinois and History of Carroll County
, ed. by Charles L. Hostetter (Chicago: Munsell, 1913), 1:119; William F. Moore and
Jane Ann Moore, Collaborators for Emancipation: Abraham Lincoln and Owen Lovejoy (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2014), 35; Karl A. Lamb, “Republican Party,”
Dictionary of American History, rev. ed. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1976), 6:92; Michael F. Holt, The Rise and Fall of the American Whig Party: Jacksonian Politics and the Onset of
the Civil War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), 805; Allen C. Guelzo, Lincoln and Douglass: The Debates that Defined America, (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2008), 10-12, 16; Michael Burlingame, Abraham Lincoln: A Life (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008), 1:562-63.
Autograph Letter Signed, 3 page(s), Abraham Lincoln Papers, Library of Congress (Washington, DC).