Abraham Lincoln to Lyman Trumbull, 29 January 18591
Springfield, Jany 29. 1859Hon: L. TrumbullDear SirI have just received your late speech, in pamphlet form, sent me by yourself– I had
seen, and read it, before, in a newspaper; and I really think it is a capital one–2 When you can find leisure, write me your present impressions of Douglas' movements–
Our friends here from different parts of the State, in and out of the Legislature, are
united, resolute, and determined; and I think it is almost certain that we shall be
far better organized
for 1860 than ever before–3
We shall get no just apportionment; and the best we can do, (if we can even do that)
is to prevent our
being made, worse than the present–4
Yours as everA. Lincoln–2Lincoln references a speech by Lyman Trumbull delivered on the floor of the U.S. Senate on January 7, 1859. Trumbull was responding to a speech by Alfred Iverson Sr. made on January 6, 1859 concerning a bill to construct a transcontinental railroad.
Railroad visionaries submitted proposals to the U.S. Congress for a railroad across the North American continent in the mid-1840s, and representatives
and senators would debate the proposed railroad’s eastern and western endpoints, funding,
and route for the next two decades as plans for the railroad became entangled with
slavery, sectional rivalry, and territorial disputes.
The route of the transcontinental railroad became a major issue during the second
session of the Thirty-Fifth Congress, which opened on December 6, 1858. President James Buchanan recommended construction of the railroad in his annual message to Congress on December
6, and the December 7, the U.S. Senate began debate on a bill for a railroad between
the Missouri River and San Francisco. The route of the railroad was a major point of contention, as construction
and use of the rail line would create massive economic growth along its route.
Iverson began his speech with a proposal for two separate rail lines, one taking a
northern route and the other taking a route through the deep South. He stated that
this was necessary, as, in his view, southern secession was inevitable, and a northern
route would be a financial donation from the South to the North. He transitioned from
speaking on the railroad to speaking on secession and the expansion of slavery, stating
“I believe that the time will come when the slave States will be compelled, in vindication
of their rights, interests, and honor, to separate from the free States, and erect
and independent Confederacy; and I am not sure, sir, that the time is not near at
hand when the event will occur. At all events, I am satisfied that one of two things
is inevitable; either that the slave States must surrender their peculiar institutions, or separate
from the North.” He threatened southern secession in the event of a Republican presidential election win and ended his speech with a call for a second rail line
that would serve the areas in which he believed would leave the Union.
Trumbull began his speech by voicing support for one rail line that was to follow
a central route before addressing Iverson’s secessionist speech from the day before.
He stated that it was inevitable that a Republican president would be elected in the
future, and that the Republican Party only advocated for stopping the spread of slavery and had no aim to end it where
it already existed. He further argued that, contrary to Iverson’s assertion that
banning the expansion of slavery was depriving equal property rights for southern
citizens, allowing slavery to be spread into new states would be denying the rights
of northern residents who wished to live in free states. He ended his speech with
a call to action, saying “When the Republican Party attains power, it will not, as
the Senator from Georgia supposes, make any encroachments on the rights of the South; but it will, I trust,
be equally ready to enforce the laws both North and South, and to call the army and
navy into requisition alike in all parts of the Republic, whenever needed for the
enforcement of law, and it can be legally and constitutionally done.” Battle over
the transcontinental railroad would continue until Congress finally passed an act
authorizing it constructive in 1862. Construction began in 1863 and would be completed
in 1869. For more on the transcontinental railroad, see Pacific Railroad (Transcontinental Railroad).
Paul W. Gates, “Union Pacific Railroad,” Dictionary of American History, rev. ed. (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1976), 7:147; U.S. Senate Journal. 1858-59. 35th Cong., 2nd sess., 3, 35-36, 39; Ralph J. Roske, His Own Counsel: The Life and Times of Lyman Trumbull (Reno, NV: University of Nevada Press, 1979), 51; Speech of Hon. A. Iverson, of Georgia, on the Pacific Railroad, Delivered in the Senate
of the United States, January 6, 1859, (Washington DC: Leonard Towers, 1859), 1-8; Remarks of Hon. Lyman Trumbull, of Illinois, in the Senate, January 7, 1859, On the
Motion to Recommit the Bill for the Construction of a Pacific railroad, with Instructions
to Bring in a Bill for the Construction of a Northern and Southern road, and in Reply
to Hon. A. Iverson (Washington DC: Buell & Blanchard, 1859), 1-7; Cong. Globe, 35th Cong., 2nd Sess.,242-44, 262-66 (1859; ); U.S. House Journal. 1862. 37th Cong., 2nd sess., 957; “An Act to Aid in the Construction of a Railroad
and Telegraph Line from the Missouri River to the Pacific Ocean, and to Secure to
the Government the Use of the Same for Postal, Military, and Other Purposes,” 1 July
1862, Statutes at Large of the United States 12 (1863):489-98; The Daily Examiner (San Francisco, CA), 10 May 1869, 2:1.
3Lincoln references the state and federal elections of 1860. Lincoln was optimistic
for Republican prospects in 1860s despite Republican struggles for unity in the state
and federal elections of 1858. Republicans experienced several threats to unity in
1858. The first came from an unexpected source: Stephen A. Douglas, the Democrat incumbent seeking reelection to the U.S. Senate. Douglas broke with President Buchanan
over the Lecompton Constitution in December 1857, splitting the Democratic Party and raising issues over Douglas’s political future . Some Republicans in the East
were excited by Douglas’s repudiation of the Lecompton Constitution to the extent
that they considered supporting his bid for reelection. Although Douglas later denied
it, he courted Republican support—meeting in person with prominent men such as Horace Greeley and hinting in correspondence with Republicans that he was finished with the Democratic
Party. Lincoln and other Republicans were concerned by these developments and urged
fellow party members to remain loyal to the Republican cause in the senatorial election.
Another threat to Republican unity came in the spring of 1858 when conservative Republicans
opposed the nomination of Owen Lovejoy for reelection to the U.S. House of Representatives from the Illinois Third Congressional District. These Republicans, many friends
of Lincoln, believed Lovejoy’s abolitionism was a threat to party interests. Recognizing the importance of Lovejoy and his supporters
for his ambitions to replace Douglas in the U.S. Senate, Lincoln warned Lovejoy of
the threat and cautioned his friends against opposing Lovejoy.
Lovejoy received the nomination, and Republicans united behind Lincoln against Douglas
for the U.S. Senate--a campaign that featured the Lincoln-Douglas Debates. Republicans won four of the nine congressional seats, including Lovejoy in the
Illinois Third Congressional District. Republicans won the popular vote in the state
elections held in November 1858 but pro-Douglas Democrats retained control of the
Illinois General Assembly, which elected U.S. senators in those days, allowing Douglas to retain his seat.
The Twenty-First Illinois General Assembly began on January 3, 1859, and ended on
February 24, 1859. Lincoln’s law office was across the street from the State Capitol
building and his house was five blocks southeast from the Capitol building. Democrats
held a forty to thirty-five advantage in the Illinois House of Representatives and a fourteen to eleven advantage in the Illinois Senate. Douglas’s reelection would be confirmed in an election held on January 5, 1859.
See 1858 Federal Election; 1858 Illinois Republican Convention.
The aftermath of the senatorial election of 1858 set the conditions for the presidential race of 1860. Through the campaign and in particular through his participation in the Lincoln-Douglas
Debates, Lincoln gained national recognition as well as standing within the national
Republican Party. Transcripts of the debates were published nationwide and brought
Lincoln to the forefront of Republican political thought. The earliest suggestions
that Lincoln run for president came days after his election loss. Israel Green, a
pharmacist in Ohio, was the first to write a public letter in support of Lincoln running for president
when he wrote to the Cincinnati Gazette on November 6, 1858. Lincoln quickly became one of the frontrunners among Republicans
in the presidential election of 1860. Lincoln would win the nomination at the 1860 Republican National Convention and the subsequent general election.
Howard W. Allen and Vincent A. Lacey, eds., Illinois Elections, 1818-1990 (Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press, 1992), 10, 11;
Illinois Senate Journal. 1859. 21st G. A., 3, 30, 582; Illinois House Journal. 1859. 21st G. A., 3, 32, 898; Allen C. Guelzo, Lincoln and Douglass: The Debates that Defined America, (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2008), 284; Allen C. Guelzo, “Houses Divided: Lincoln,
Douglas, and the Political Landscape of 1858,” The Journal of American History 94 (September 2007), 392-94, 414-16; Daily Illinois State Journal (Springfield), 3 November 1858, 2:1;Washington Post(DC), 3 October 1915, 13:2; Michael Burlingame, Abraham Lincoln: A Life (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008), 1:445-50; 456-47; 458-60,
492-540, 556-57; George Fort Milton, "Lincoln-Douglas Debates," Dictionary of American
History, rev. ed. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1976), 4:155-56.
4Apportionment of seats in the Illinois General Assembly cost Lincoln the U.S. Senate
election The voting districts in Illinois were created using the 1850 census and the northern, Republican voting districts
increased much quicker in population than the southern, Democratic voting districts
in the eight years between the census and the election of 1858. Republicans received
50 percent of the popular vote and 46 percent of the Illinois General Assembly while
Democrats won 48 percent of the popular vote and 54 percent of the Illinois General
Assembly. According to the Sangamo Journal, “The thirty five Lincoln members of the House represent a larger population than the forty Douglas members; and the eleven Lincoln
Senators represent a larger constitnency than the fourteen Douglas and Buchanan senators. ...In the Republican districts
it requires on an average a population of 19,635 inhabitants to elect a representative,
and 58,900 for a Senator, while in the Democratic districts 15,675 for a representative
and 47,100 for a Senator suffices. On a fair apportionment, Douglas would have been
beaten seven in the House and three in the Senate.” Trumbull’s reelection to the U.S. Senate depended on the Republicans winning the
Illinois General Assembly in 1860, and many Republican leaders in Illinois were fearful
Democrats would gerrymander the House and Senate districts to keep control of the
General Assembly. In the state elections of 1860, Republicans won control of both
the Illinois House of Representatives and the Illinois Senate, gaining a one seat
majority in the Senate and five seat majority in the House, allowing Trumbull to win
reelection.
Michael Burlingame, Abraham Lincoln: A Life, 1:546-47; Daily Illinois State Journal (Springfield), 9 November 1858, 2:1; 6 January 1859, 2:2; Illinois Daily State Journal (Springfield), 11 December 1860, 2:3; The Ottawa Free Trader (IL), 15 December 1860, 1:6; Illinois Senate Journal. 1855. 19th G. A., 255; Illinois Senate Journal. 1861. 22th G. A., 32;
Illinois House Journal. 1861. 22th G. A., 31.
Autograph Letter Signed, 1 page(s), Huntington Library (San Marino, CA).